Originally Posted By: jk_636
Originally Posted By: Shannow
Originally Posted By: jk_636
All additives run out eventually. Isn't that why we pay the extra couple bucks to Blackstone to get a TBN? Arguably, diff. oil needs to be changed every 30-100k miles depending on the severity of service.
Wrong test, wrong idea...
Acids are formed in engines by the products of combustion and moisture, and are neutralised by the alkali reserves in the oil....more acid forming fuel (like sulfur rich bunker oil), more TBN in the oil...typically those marine engines would have a separate lubricant compartment for the bearings, and one for the pistons/blowby high TBN oil (and the crosshead).
Unless you have a real problem, you don't have combustion residue in your differential, and wouldn't be requesting a TBN (the additives are acidic also).
Diff oil, depending on VII may thin down some, but unless loaded with dust/water, or goes too thin...it doesn't need to be changed that often.
Wrong again. The idea was that after enough heat and friction, additives and oils begin to break down and degrade. Both condition are found in rear differentials, especially those that tow consistently heavy loads.
No, he's quite right. TBN testing is useless for a diff because it doesn't see combustion byproducts. Also, as per Doug Hillary's post, it sounds like additive break-down is not as big an issue as we think it is.