Need Ideas - Recommend Used Vehicle for Sister

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
5,805
Location
Dickson, TN.
Hey folks, my sister was involved in an accident.

She is fine; she was driving her 2004 Explorer when a lady pulled out and hit her pass. side. Luckily she and my 2-yr-old nephew are fine. But the Exploder is probably going to be totaled. Too bad, as they just spent beaucoups of $$$ getting the transmission rebuilt.

Anyway, I'm trying to steer her towards something Japanese. Not really sure what all she would consider; her rental is a Suburban and she likes it. Today she mentioned something about a Tahoe.

I think she wants something fairly large - I don't think she'd consider anything like a mid-sized car. Not even sure she'd entertain the idea of a large car. She might.

As I mentioned, they have a 2-year-old, and will probably have another kid within the next couple of years. In the past, they have mentioned the Sienna and Odyssey.

Personally I think a Sienna or even a Highlander or a Lexus RX (for the right deal) would be nice choices.

I've read here that Honda FWD V6s have transmission problems. But the problem was fixed after a certain model year? What are the years to avoid? Did any of the Toyota FWD V6s suffer problems?

The reasons I'm trying to steer her away from a large SUV like a Tahoe and towards something mid-size, FWD, V6 are:

- efficiency
- reliability
- easier to maneuver & park (all her driving is urban/suburban - almost all city streets, grocery store parking lots, gym, etc)

They are buying used. Thankfully, the Exploder was paid for. They'll probably get around 5-6 grand for it. They're not in a position to buy anything outright, and my bro-in-law doesn't work on cars at all. So they need something with fairly low miles, reliable, preferably with some factory warranty left on it.

Her husband works for FedEx, and is a member of the credit union, so that's where they'll likely borrow the funds from. I'm trying to encourage them to stay away from the dealer and buy from an individual (unless they can find a sweet deal on a certified used vehicle).

Anyway, I appreciate y'all's input. I respect the opinions of those here, and I just wanted to bounce some ideas off you guys in this thread, and possibly some prices when we find some potential vehicles.

And, if anyone here in the TN-ARK-MS area has something for sale that sounds like something they'd consider, by all means let me know!


Thanks,

John
 
subaru forester?
smile.gif
 
Originally Posted By: Rand
subaru forester?
smile.gif



She's not a lesbien
smile.gif


Nah, just kidding. I love Subarus - I think they're great, unique cars. But, I think my sister wouldn't consider one.
 
The newer Escapes are nice. No experience with the Equinox. My personal opinion is that the newer Fords are more reliable and more refined than GM/Chevy, at least in the small-mid size car/SUV segments.
 
Honda Pilot, Honda CRV, Toyota Highlander, Toyota 4Runner, Nissan Pathfinder, maybe Toyota Sienna or Honda Odyssey. These are all good solid choices for a Japanese family hauler. And as far as Honda transmission go, I think they are all trouble prone to a degree as they have a unique design that does not seem to handle lots of torque well...but as long as you treat it right and dont beat on it, and change the transmission fluid (with only Honda ATF) OFTEN they seem to work just fine.
 
Originally Posted By: HardbodyLoyalist
The problem is that "large SUV" and "easy to maneuver/park" are contradictory requirements.


No, I said that those were the reasons I'm trying to steer her AWAY from a large SUV.

THAT SAID, I don't think she's gonna consider an Escape/CRV/RAV, etc. I think mid-size, like a Highlander, Pathfinder, Pilot, or a minivan, are gonna be the smallest she'll consider.
 
The fuel economy of the Tahoe is not really that much worse than a 2004 Explorer 4.0.

Reliability? I'm continuously amazed when people bring in Tahoes with paper temp tags that have over 150,000 miles on them. The detailer at the lot did a good job cleaning it up and it still runs and drives well.

Parking and maneuverability? Yeah...it's big, But it doesn't have the "Give me 40 acres and I'll turn this rig around..." turning radius of older GM trucks
 
A larger vehicle's gonna get worse.

Anyway, she vetoed the minivan idea.

It appears she likes traditional, boxy, body-on-frame SUVs.

Hates crossovers, God bless her.
 
Out of the mid-sized SUV's the 4Runner is my favorite but she would probably like the Pilot, it feels absolutely huge inside.
 
Originally Posted By: john_pifer
her rental is a Suburban and she likes it. Today she mentioned something about a Tahoe.
Then why doesn't she get one of those?
 
If she can stand too look at it minivan(Sienna or Odyssey with vcm). This is coming from the owner of a wonderful 07 Acura MDX. Way more usable.
 
The minivan stereotype is hard to get passed but with small kid(s) it is hard to beat. Easy to put in seats, no doors swinging wide banging in parking lots. Higher ride height, point of view etc. Normally better fuel mileage.

My wife and I love her '03 Sequoia EXCEPT that mileage thing. Around town short trip if you get 10mpg it's a good day. A couple friends have the Pilot and if replacing the Sequoia at this point that would be real high on my list as well as a Forester.

First she needs to figure out budget and then what she needs vs. wants and for how long. Minivan for 5-6 years then sell/trade. 2WD (front or rear), AWD, 4WD. Snow/winter concerns? Hauling lots of stuff (besides baby things)

I wanted many things when I bought my '07 Sonata but I needed lower priced reliable and able to fit 4 comfortably with decent trunk space. Stability control, ABS, Manual transmission was mandatory for me. Camry was 21k plus taxes, Sonata was $16,400 after taxes/rebates etc. It now has 111k on it and runs great.

That said this past winters snows I would have gone nowhere without the Sequoia my block/road didn't get plowed for 4 days. The snow was up to the hood on the Sonata and I had to go to work.
 
Whats wrong with the "BIG BURB" she's driving now ? U said she liked it , no? BIG safe do all on 4 wheels.....a tank in the winter too !! The turning radius on a Suburban is tight like a frogs u know what. It's 17 inches longer than a Yukon and plenty of room for the family now and later.
The 4Runner...Seqouia... fit the call of what she's looking for too. GO BIG.....I bet she was glad she was in a big vehicle when she had the accident....right?
BOB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom