62,000 miles on a rental is yucky. Time for that one to filter down to the local "Ugly Duckling" rental lot..... Assuming those guys are still in business.
Like was mentioned, rentals are in short supply nowadays, but this is really pushing it. What company was it? Can you pick and choose from amongst a row of cars? I rent from Dollar and typically within whatever row they let be pick from there is always a low-mileage creampuff. Dollar is the low-priced subsidiary of Hertz and lots of people hate them but they have always been good to me.
It really is different today. I like to browse enterprise car sales online given I've bought from them pre-pandemic.
Today they're wanting $25K+ for 2-3 year old ex-rental Nissan Altimas with ~60K miles on them. That's about $10K more than 2yrs ago.
It seems they don't even consider taking something out of rental service until it hits 60K+ miles.