Originally Posted by MolaKule
In my view, any fluid meeting the specs is better than Nissan OEM fluids.
I'm of the opinion that there's nothing magical about Nissan or most OEM's fluids. I don't believe that Mobil 1, Castrol, Valvoline, etc would say one of their fluids is okay to use in a vehicle if it really wasn't. I mean, most of them make multiple fluids for this reason - they know where it works and where it doesn't.
I have no proof and it's just speculation, but I think plenty of OEM fluids are just re-labeled off-the-shelf fluids. I can see an automaker spec'ing a fluid that needs A, B, C characteristics and soliciting "bids" from the oil/fluid manufacturers. Plenty of them may come back and say (using Castrol as a simple example), "our Transmax Import Multi-Vehicle meets all of your specs and exceeds some of them". Valvoline could say the same and so on with others.