MK7 GTI needs new AC Condenser (OEM/Nissens/Mahle Behr)

Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
45
Location
Bayonne NJ
Hi all,

Today's the first 85 degree day here in Northern NJ. When using my AC on full blast, the compressor cycles off after a few minutes but if I keep it under 6 for the setting. The AC will function as normally, albeit not super cold as it used to.

About 2 years back, I ran over a dead deer coming back from Pittsburgh to Jersey. Traveled a lot for work and never got around to replacing the condenser as it didn't seem to be leaking. It does look a little bent up from the deer collision however.

So, I am going to bring it to a shop and have them evacuate the freon. But I am running into a parts dilemma, as the OEM condenser is very expensive ($500) from FCP Euro or the dealer. Car is paid off and I plan on keeping it for as long as possible, but it's up there in age now 8 years old and 120k miles. Owned it since 34k.

Do I toss in a OEM condenser or go with a Nissens ($96) or Mahle Behr ($130) condenser? They all come with the drier, so I am good there. Just don't want to end up replacing it again so soon or have the AC fail on me during the summer months.

Unfortunately, according to FCP Euro it shows that both the Nissens and Mahle are both made in China. With the Mahle being listed as an OEM equivalent not that it matters much....

What would you all do? I figured I would keep this car going as long as I can.
 
Don’t expect the Behr to last as long as the original. Probably 3-4 years if I had to put a number on it. I’d bet similar on the Nissens.
 
Don’t expect the Behr to last as long as the original. Probably 3-4 years if I had to put a number on it. I’d bet similar on the Nissens.
Fair enough, I'll be considering that then.

Side question, I have seen these GTIs with a fair amount of evaporator failures.

How does one prevent that from happening?
 
Truth is the best aftermarket condensers perform about 80% as well as the OEM. The fin spacing is to blame. This is due to a single tooling needing to cover a lot of models. There’s a YouTube AC savant Tom Lech that has a lot of videos analyzing various aftermarket condensers and it’s never good. In your scenario I’d bite the bullet and go OEM personally.
 
Does Denso offer one for your car?

My current and past Mercedes had a lot of Denso ac components, including the compressor (not sure about condenser tbh)
 
Fair enough, I'll be considering that then.

Side question, I have seen these GTIs with a fair amount of evaporator failures.

How does one prevent that from happening?
They happen for sure - we’ve done/seen quite a few but honestly not enough that I’d be that worried about it happening
 
Does Denso offer one for your car?

My current and past Mercedes had a lot of Denso ac components, including the compressor (not sure about condenser tbh)
Denso was absolute crap in VW Passat B5.5. Denso makes ok stuff, but IMO nothing better than other OE suppliers.
 
Back
Top Bottom