Mises

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Nov 16, 2002
Messages
40,125
Location
NJ
http://mises.org/

I never realized how "outcast" the Austrian School is considered. The guy that wrote my Economics textbook, hasn't even read his work! How is that possible?

http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2006/04/austrian-economics.html

Quote:
The truthful, if slightly embarrassing, answer is that I have not read the book. Explaining why may be somewhat edifying, however, so let me reflect on the reasons (not excuses) for my ignorance.

First, most economists at research universities focus their attention on recent work. Things written more than twenty or thirty years ago are usually assumed to be irrelevant, out-dated, or incorporated into more recent work. We rarely focus on something like the Mises book (written in 1949) for the same reason that physicists don't read Newton in the original.

Second, at the mainstream schools where I have spent my education and career (Princeton, MIT, and Harvard), the economists of the Austrian school like Mises are often viewed as fringe figures. Rightly or wrongly, they rarely show up on reading lists. I am confident that while I was a student at Princeton and MIT, I was assigned not a single article by an economist in the Austrian tradition.

That judgment might well be unfair. Another prominent Austrian economist is Friedrich Hayek, who won the Nobel prize in economics. Cognizant of my ignorance of his work, a few years ago I read (and assigned in a Harvard freshman seminar) his classic book The Road to Serfdom. I thought it was terrific.
 
The truthful, if slightly embarassing, answer is that I did not read your post.

How is the Mrs.?
wink.gif
 
Originally Posted By: oilyriser
Originally Posted By: moribundman
You can't buy karma.


I bought a used karma.

A buddy of mine had a Karma Ghia in high school.
 
Seriously, on the original topic --

Though I know nada about economics beyond the ol' supply-and-demand rule, I work for a bunch of economics professors. I've never heard any of them mention the difference between Keynesian theory and Austrian (the Ludwig von Mises school, correct?). What I've gathered from reading about the current econ meltdown is the following: the Austrians believe that if their principles had been followed vs. those of the Keynesians, we'd have avoided all this.

Now every school thinks it has the right answer. So, in words of one syllable, what is it that the Austrian school recommends, and what is it that the Keynes school recommends? Do the former believe in a hands-off approach by government, and the Keynes guys believe the government should plunge right into the markets?
 
Originally Posted By: Benzadmiral
Originally Posted By: oilyriser
Originally Posted By: moribundman
You can't buy karma.


I bought a used karma.

A buddy of mine had a Karma Ghia in high school.


That was just the psychedelics working, that transformed your buddies car into a vehicle in which you could observe your own connectedness.
 
Originally Posted By: Benzadmiral
Originally Posted By: oilyriser
Originally Posted By: moribundman
You can't buy karma.


I bought a used karma.

A buddy of mine had a Karma Ghia in high school.


My karma just ran over your dogma.
 
Originally Posted By: Benzadmiral
Seriously, on the original topic --

Though I know nada about economics beyond the ol' supply-and-demand rule, I work for a bunch of economics professors. I've never heard any of them mention the difference between Keynesian theory and Austrian (the Ludwig von Mises school, correct?). What I've gathered from reading about the current econ meltdown is the following: the Austrians believe that if their principles had been followed vs. those of the Keynesians, we'd have avoided all this.

Now every school thinks it has the right answer. So, in words of one syllable, what is it that the Austrian school recommends, and what is it that the Keynes school recommends? Do the former believe in a hands-off approach by government, and the Keynes guys believe the government should plunge right into the markets?


Austrian School: Fiat money bad, gold standard good.
Keynesians: Money created through debt instruments good, gold standard bad.
 
Originally Posted By: XS650
Originally Posted By: Benzadmiral
Originally Posted By: oilyriser
Originally Posted By: moribundman
You can't buy karma.


I bought a used karma.

A buddy of mine had a Karma Ghia in high school.


My karma just ran over your dogma.


My dogma caught your karma and peeed on the tires.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom