is this a lightning strike on tree?

Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
1,072
Last week had a windstorm roll through the area . mother woke up a found the tree in the yard down. tree has been there for a looong time . The tree trunk was a Y shape . Looking at it i was thinking it was struck by lightening . Closer exam i think there are burn marks where it splits into 2

So what do you guys think ?

tree3.webp


tree2.webp


tree.webp
 
I'd say so. I don't think the wind snapped that tree and it looks burnt.
 
It doesn't look like it to me. The lightning struck tree's I've seen were hit near the top. It's unlikely that it would hit down at a crotch near the base.
 
It would smell burnt if it was burnt. We had one 20" dbh pine that was struck actually burn 5-6' up into some dryrot in the middle the trunk, and fall over. Fortunately this didn't start a bigger fire as it was borderline dry in the woods.
 
No. A lightning strike would travel up/down the trunk more and blast/separate the bark from the wood . Those double stem V's are very weak joints subject to lots of moisture/fungus/rot. Lots of pics on the interweb.
 
No. A lightning strike would travel up/down the trunk more and blast/separate the bark from the wood . Those double stem V's are very weak joints subject to lots of moisture/fungus/rot. Lots of pics on the interweb.

Certainly with a smaller tree. I've seen giant sequoias up close and all big ones were previously hit by lightning. Some had several visible strikes where you could see holes in the trunk near the top and some near the base. The path it might take could be random.
 
No. It looks like it was 2 trees that were just growing together. The brown area that looks burned is just dirty wet bark. You can see fungus growing on it.

The tree finally split in half from the wind.
 
looks like a rotted crotch in the tree and wind took it down, not a lightning strike, if it were a lightning strike the bark usually is off mostly at the lower trunk.
 
I saw a big pine tree hit by lightning once. It made a loud cracking sound and the top portion shattered into hundreds of large burnt toothpicks. I was close enough to feel a bit of the electricity in the air. I seek shelter now when lightning is possible.
 
Those pictures look more like rot to me, but I would have to see them up close in person to really make a decision. Lightning does some weird stuff. I'm no expert though.

I have a decent chunk of acreage and I find lightning strikes every now and then. Here are the two most recent ones, I know these were lightning because I have an app on my phone that tells me where the closest strikes are, and these both pegged on the app.

The first picture, the limb got blown off and the burnt area is about five feet or so long, and does not go all the way to the ground. It stopped where the limb attached to the main trunk. Interestingly, this tree survived, but the tree next to it and the honeysuckle bushes right next to it all started to wither within a few days and a few weeks later were very clearly dead, and I ended up taking a chainsaw to them not long after. Ironically, the tree that took the strike still lives on to this day, minus one big limb.

The second picture is a strike that hit right behind my garage/workshop, and the burn area is about 3-4 feet up and goes all the way down to the ground, and there is a very small burned area on the ground. The trunk in this picture that took the strike broke off the other three trunks and fell a few days later but the rest of the tree is fine and is still alive.
lightning.webp
Lightning 2.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom