How's this for misinformation?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Messages
7,581
Location
KY
I've been thinking of picking up an Abarth so I've been monitoring one of the Fiat 500 forums. It turns out that the Abarth and the 500 Turbo spec a 5W-40 synthetic, while non-turbo 500s takes any SN 5W-30. An Abarth owner was worried that his dealer had used 5W-30 instead of the 5W-40 synthetic and posed his concerns. The following is one "expert" response:

It must be true.. Its on the internets...

Want answers??? Call an oil manufacturer. They HAVE all the facts. They will be more than happy to help a customer.


Most people that post stuff are reposters. I.. Myself have been an engine repair and builder for 30 years. I have been to seminars and shows to learn about oil and its differences between regular oil and synthetic. I also know the effects of oils and ethanol and methanol. (I am also the Crew chief for a NASA Spec E30 car and a Chumpcar, and a back up crew for a Porsche 993 NASA GT3 car.)
The only thing that makes an oil synthetic is that the amount of additives exceeds a certain percentage. Its still all oil.

Want to make your own synthetic oil?? Change your oil. First thing you put in, 1/2 qt of transmission fluid. Then top off with the motor oil of your choice. The amount of detergents and additives in the trans fluid will make the oil"synthetic" by the rules. Before you get all bothered.. This is what we did on cars back in the days of straight oils and engines with coking problems. One customer had Dodge trucks that they bought new and sold with 350,000 on them. (With the unopened factory engines)
I now only do this on turbo engines that aren't water cooled turbos. (Castrol GTX does a great job of keeping engines clean inside.)
Heck.. you can use vegetable oil if you can find a way to stabilize it. (You know.. by additives.. and you make a synthetic oil)
So... Fear not.. your car is going to be OK. Your turbo is safe. (I have experience in this stuff.)


Comments?
 
I knew it! All along I knew it! And I have five gallons of leftover peanut oil from our last family fish fry and six oz of Vavoline Maxlife that I've been itching to pour somewhere since yesterday. FIVE GALLONS OF EARTH FRIENDLY SYNTHETIC OIL COMING RIGHT UP!!!!
 
Originally Posted By: MCompact
(I am also the Crew chief for a NASA Spec E30 car and a Chumpcar,

Comments?


It's no wonder all their funding was cut.
 
Quote:
Want to make your own synthetic oil?? Change your oil. First thing you put in, 1/2 qt of transmission fluid. Then top off with the motor oil of your choice. The amount of detergents and additives in the trans fluid will make the oil"synthetic" by the rules. Before you get all bothered.. This is what we did on cars back in the days of straight oils and engines with coking problems.


He's just telling you this so your engine won't 'splode
shocked2.gif
grin2.gif
 
another self-proclaimed expert on the internet. Although back in the day of poor oils with few additives, a qt of ATF that was based on whale oil, probably gave those early oils a lot better performance for keeping engines clean and lowering wear. I know people that still do this and will never stop until they blow something up, because it really worked back then. We are talking about lubricants from 40-60 years ago. Some habits die hard.
 
Originally Posted By: GreeCguy
I knew it! All along I knew it! And I have five gallons of leftover peanut oil from our last family fish fry and six oz of Vavoline Maxlife that I've been itching to pour somewhere since yesterday. FIVE GALLONS OF EARTH FRIENDLY SYNTHETIC OIL COMING RIGHT UP!!!!


That will be fine but if you use vegetable oil you should add Cholesterol testing to our next UOA. Also, you will need to drive fast the night before the sample is taken,
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: cmorr
Originally Posted By: GreeCguy
I knew it! All along I knew it! And I have five gallons of leftover peanut oil from our last family fish fry and six oz of Vavoline Maxlife that I've been itching to pour somewhere since yesterday. FIVE GALLONS OF EARTH FRIENDLY SYNTHETIC OIL COMING RIGHT UP!!!!


That will be fine but if you use vegetable oil you should add Cholesterol testing to our next UOA. Also, you will need to drive fast the night before the sample is taken,

I thought you weren't supposed to drive the night before.
smirk.gif
 
I think some people make up stupid stuff like that and then search for it later to see how many people have reposted it.
 
I had a retired (European) mechanic tell me (and show me) that a rusty ball-joint was OK cause you can clean it up with sandpaper and then throw new grease on it. Good as new!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom