NO. It should be generally more efficient.
That car is 1-3/4 tonnes with driver and not "tiny" with size and weighs very close to the mid-sized 7th gen Accord
Just noticed it's a new car;
1.5 Turbo DI? How carbon fluffy black is the tail pipe? How is the oil level?
I say Give it another 200 mile cycle with fresh fuel.
Was this assertion Based this on the 34 mile trip as displayed on you DIC ? - That's not conclusive data.
What octane does it require? I find middle-grade (AKI r+m/2) "Premium" fuels often un-pumped and stale. So, I would use 87. Or blend you own by pumping twice 3/4 of 87 then 1/4 of 93AKI) My search shows Costco is Top Tier additised fuel. That is pretty much required these days. You didn't add any extra cleansers did you? That would be too much detergent = BAD.
Did you just replace that moly laden FF break-in oil? '
You are in the "dregs of engine wear in" where the engine is not particularly happy.
Somtimes I start my car, don't let it warm up for a 1/2 min to go closed loop and dirve off and the thing, it won't run right. Experienced this too many tomes. If I can stop, shut her down for 3-5min and reboot - many time that will get it back to good running.
But a proper running Honda? Typically No way that low on mpg. But the super high compression D.I turbos may need special care and feeding. It may be pulling timing and covering pre-ignition knock with over-fueling.
And just to be thorough, insure there are no squirrels or 'munks taking up residence in the airbox.
- Ken