Green Filter quote

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 25, 2006
Messages
4,168
Location
Olathe, KS
I've been researching various filters for my 3.5 Duratec. Unfortunately, only Green and red (K&N) have a replacement drop-in. I want an aFe pro Dry S, but it's not available. I've read that Greens may flow the best -- meaning they probably allow more dirt in. This quote from their website immediately turned me off:

Economical - A paper filter should be replaced between 4,000 to 5,000 miles or every oil change. The average cost of a paper filter is about $10 to $12. After one year of driving 15,000 miles, at least 3 paper filters are needed. This totals $30 to $35. After one to two years, a Lifetime Green Filter is already paid for. This benefit is for everyone - a daily driver, an older vehicle or someone looking for the best performance.

I don't know who recommends replacing a paper filter every 4-5k mi? I guess Green Filter for one! For the record, my OEM filter still looks brand new at 3000 mi. I'm expecting a lot of dirt these next 1-2000 miles.
crazy.gif
 
Pep boys recommends doing every filter every 12k... Noted that last time I was in the store.
 
Wow, I must be way out there, I am at 100K kms (62k miles) with my factory filter, still looks clean, but we don't get much dust here...my Suburban filter takes quite a while to get dirty too at least 125K kms (80K miles), but it sees at bit more dusty environment.
 
They recommend every 4-5k because it makes their replacement filter look more economical when you do a cost comparison. Anybody can make their product look cost effective with irrational claims about the OEM product it is replacing.
 
Originally Posted By: zulu
They recommend every 4-5k because it makes their replacement filter look more economical when you do a cost comparison. Anybody can make their product look cost effective with irrational claims about the OEM product it is replacing.


+1 An air filter change at every oil change??? WOW
 
Originally Posted By: zulu
They recommend every 4-5k because it makes their replacement filter look more economical when you do a cost comparison. Anybody can make their product look cost effective with irrational claims about the OEM product it is replacing.


Exactly, but those with any clue will stay far away from anyone making such claims.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom