FICO Score Inflation?

Joined
Apr 28, 2020
Messages
2,380
Location
North Dakota
Within the past few months I've noticed my FICO gain 20+ points despite no major changes other than me closing a card that has had a zero balance for quite some time. In theory, that should have caused a score decrease due to a loss of available credit, yes? Curious if they went to a different scoring metric now that caused increases across the board? Anyone else see unexplained movement? FICO now tracks the oil market maybe? 😆
 
A FICO Score is something that controls your life and that you have no control over. In other words, it's the perfect scam. No one will ever know what their FICO Score is because the ratings agencies give different numbers depending upon who is asking. Why do we submit to this nonsense?
 
Within the past few months I've noticed my FICO gain 20+ points despite no major changes other than me closing a card that has had a zero balance for quite some time. In theory, that should have caused a score decrease due to a loss of available credit, yes? Curious if they went to a different scoring metric now that caused increases across the board? Anyone else see unexplained movement? FICO now tracks the oil market maybe? 😆
No, not necessarily.
The FICO formula is very intricate and personal to each individual depending on all the circumstances on your credit history.
With that said it can go either way. Being you closed down an unused line of credit in this case, I would suggest the credit agency see’s that as less opportunity for you to get overextended in debt.

That brings us back to FICO score is intimately associated with the specific individual.
An individual can have a large amount of available unused revolving credit to them, and that will be a negative on your credit report. It will be listed as “ too much available revolving credit”

I used to get that on my credit report. I’ve always had excellent credit scores but at times a massive amount of available revolving unused credit so that would be one negative.
Don’t take that as a negative everybody has negatives on credit reports it doesn’t mean it’s bad it just gives a reason for the report that you have.
We charge a lot of things in our family, but we pay them every month always have. Everything we charge we get cash back on so once in a while, I will change out cards for a better deal and when I have a card that I am not using and know, I will never be using it. I cancel it.

Sometimes credit card companies offer me for example $350 to open up a credit card with them.
I will open it up use it for a few months to collect the $350 and then close it out. That would be one example.
 
Last edited:
No, not necessarily.
The FICO formula is very intricate and personal to each individual depending on all the circumstances on your credit history.
With that said it can go either way. Being you closed down an unused line of credit in this case, I would suggest the credit agency see’s that as less opportunity for you to get overextended in debt.

With all due respect, go to your 1) bank, 2) mortgage broker 3) credit card company, 4) Experian website, 5) Transunion website, 6) Equifax website and get your FICO Scores. Then, come back and tell us how many were the same number.

"The FICO formula"? That can be found in Brigadoon. You pass Shangri-La on the way.
 
I never look at my FICO score but when I recently put a freeze on the 3 credit entities discovered wife and I have identical scores in the mid 800s. Not sure how that's possible but good for a laugh.

I did the same thing, but my three scores were not the same.
 
With all due respect, go to your 1) bank, 2) mortgage broker 3) credit card company, 4) Experian website, 5) Transunion website, 6) Equifax website and get your FICO Scores. Then, come back and tell us how many were the same number.

"The FICO formula"? That can be found in Brigadoon. You pass Shangri-La on the way.
Pretty much always within 10 to 20 points of each other.
I’ve had a string of months with a perfect 850 score.
Not sure why you would look for a perfect number between all three.
There is three main credit reporting companies giving scores. It really doesn’t matter if your credit score is the same. Companies that loan money use categories of scores with about a 60 point swing or so.

If you have really really good credit car deal is when they run those 0% financing only the top couple percent will actually qualify for that. I know a lot about credit scores and we qualify for anything and everything.
 
My B-of-A FICO score went up unexpectedly by about 15 points a few months ago.. Found out they changed the FICO score they were using. There are quite a few apparently
 
1) If there is a formula, why is there a variance?

2) Are you saying that you checked six scores from six different sources?
 
A FICO Score is something that controls your life and that you have no control over. In other words, it's the perfect scam. No one will ever know what their FICO Score is because the ratings agencies give different numbers depending upon who is asking. Why do we submit to this nonsense?
Who's submitting to what? While I'm aware of what my scores are roughly though all the "free monitoring" offers through the various financial institutions I use, these scores require nothing of me beyond what I would be doing anyway - paying my bills on time.
 
Until a few months ago my B of A FICO score was always 15-20 points lower than Trans Union or Experian. Now they are within a point or so. I do know there is a FICO 6 and a FICO 8 rating.
 
Sometimes credit card companies offer me for example $350 to open up a credit card with them.
I will open it up use it for a few months to collect the $350 and then close it out. That would be one example.
That was my example...opened this card a year ago for a great bonus offer, hit the spending minimum to get said bonus, and then put a calendar reminder to close it before the annual fee hit. I'm all for playing the game too, although I'm only interested in the game if it pays $600+ on the offer.
 
Who's submitting to what? While I'm aware of what my scores are roughly though all the "free monitoring" offers through the various financial institutions I use, these scores require nothing of me beyond what I would be doing anyway - paying my bills on time.

If you want a mortgage, a credit card, a bank account, etc., they run your credit. Some employers run your credit.
 
My score, from 5 different sources, including a Volvo truck dealer, allweld, a semi tanker trailer builder, and 3 online credit score places i check regularly, are all so close together, they may as well be the same. Lowest was 863, highest 867, so it really doesn't matter which you want to go with. If anyone cares, Credit karma scored me lowest, and volvo dealership the highest.
 
There are many different FICO/credit score products used by different lenders, e.g. mortgage lender may be different from a bank extending a credit card vs car loans, etc. I keep my credit accounts frozen and only thawed twice in the past several years. I asked the institution which credit bureau they used and only thawed that account and only for a couple of days.
 
Well, if you guys say that all is well in FICO Land, I'm willing to be corrected.
 
If you want a mortgage, a credit card, a bank account, etc., they run your credit. Some employers run your credit.
OK...but by "submit to", I read that as why do we allow/participate in the burden of FICO scores? The answer is because we have no choice other than to be financially responsible which I'd be doing anyway even if FICO scores didn't exist. The fact they exist and can be different is no skin off my nose whatsoever.
 
Back
Top Bottom