Red Wing #4406 is my daily wear work book.
Best advice: Think about what exactly you want your boot to accomplish. For me, I must have steel toes, and they must be waterproof, and comfortable enough to wear daily, on my feet for hours at a time on both hard and soft surfaces. Made in the USA is preferable. I got my first pair of these in 1998 and haven't looked back. (Still US made but with imported materials on this boot - other Red Wing boots will vary).
I wear other types of boots, including cowboy boots, hunting boots, snow boots, etc... depending on what I am doing, but I would decide what it most important and shop from there.