Coffee makers...what works best for you?

Joined
Aug 3, 2024
Messages
230
I wouldn't say I was a hardcore coffee snob, I'll drain a few cups at my favorite cafe or taqueria without complaint, but I do find that using the right machine/technique with the proper bean certainly makes for a better cup at home. For me a high-quality drip machine can do the job, but the real game changer is how the coffee is kept hot. Most of the cheap "Mr Coffee" style machines have a glass carafe sitting on a hotplate to keep the coffee at a drinkable temperature, and that's where they get a deservedly bad rap. Before long that hotplate will give the coffee a bitter, stewed taste that we've all experienced at some point, but fortunately there's a better option...the thermal carafe.

My first one was made by Melitta, which worked on the same principle as the standard drip machine but had a stainless steel insulated carafe that kept the coffee plenty warm for several hours, more than long enough for my wife and I to drink "12 cups" (seriously?). After a few years it started leaking so we found a Keurig machine that also had a metal carafe and could do K-Cups as well as a full pot. This one seems to do a better job at extraction resulting in a very smooth brew and the carafe keeps the coffee hot for quite a few hours. We don't use the K-Cups all that often but my wife like to make a flavored coffee every now and then, which is not my thing.

Coffee-wise I wasn't always that picky until my aforementioned bride, who's a closet Pacific Islander, turned me on to the Hawaiian varieties. Fortunately my local grocery store sells a whole-bean Kona blend in bulk that does the job nicely, unfortunately we both have to cut down on our caffeine intake so we do a 50/50 blend with a quality decaf. Not the same as the high octane stuff but better than nothing.

In short, what do you fine folks like to use the prepare your morning brew...French press, an old-school percolator, a high end espresso maker or just your basic drip machine? Whatever it is it certainly beats waiting in line for an overpriced, mediocre cup of warm brown water.
 
We have 2 identical model Moccamasters... primary home and beach house. A Baratza Encore grinder in main house and a fairly new Oxo grinder in the beach house. Also have a Gaggia Brera superautomatic espresso machine in the beach house.
Grinding the beans right before brewing makes a huge difference.
Go to beans are Peet's Major Dickisons. Costco Colombian Supremo, Costco House Blend.
View attachment 298215

20220113_153203_HDR.webp
1756712392862.webp
 
I have a French press but I quit drinking hot coffee and don't miss it. My wife has a Kerueg machine and uses it everyday.
 
I wouldn't say I was a hardcore coffee snob, I'll drain a few cups at my favorite cafe or taqueria without complaint, but I do find that using the right machine/technique with the proper bean certainly makes for a better cup at home. For me a high-quality drip machine can do the job, but the real game changer is how the coffee is kept hot. Most of the cheap "Mr Coffee" style machines have a glass carafe sitting on a hotplate to keep the coffee at a drinkable temperature, and that's where they get a deservedly bad rap. Before long that hotplate will give the coffee a bitter, stewed taste that we've all experienced at some point, but fortunately there's a better option...the thermal carafe.

My first one was made by Melitta, which worked on the same principle as the standard drip machine but had a stainless steel insulated carafe that kept the coffee plenty warm for several hours, more than long enough for my wife and I to drink "12 cups" (seriously?). After a few years it started leaking so we found a Keurig machine that also had a metal carafe and could do K-Cups as well as a full pot. This one seems to do a better job at extraction resulting in a very smooth brew and the carafe keeps the coffee hot for quite a few hours. We don't use the K-Cups all that often but my wife like to make a flavored coffee every now and then, which is not my thing.

Coffee-wise I wasn't always that picky until my aforementioned bride, who's a closet Pacific Islander, turned me on to the Hawaiian varieties. Fortunately my local grocery store sells a whole-bean Kona blend in bulk that does the job nicely, unfortunately we both have to cut down on our caffeine intake so we do a 50/50 blend with a quality decaf. Not the same as the high octane stuff but better than nothing.

In short, what do you fine folks like to use the prepare your morning brew...French press, an old-school percolator, a high end espresso maker or just your basic drip machine? Whatever it is it certainly beats waiting in line for an overpriced, mediocre cup of warm brown water.
I have a percolator and wouldn't have it any other way. My friends say my tastes are finicky but once I started using a burr grinder for coffee beans vs my parents always using a spice grinder I found the taste was always smoother and noticeably better. I just can't get past the waste of Keurig cups even though now there are reusable cups for them.
 
My wife is less picky than I am, so I make hers in a Moccamaster. She found a coffee blend she likes at our grocery store. I use a V60 pour-over technique and Comandante hand grinder. My beans came from Sey Coffee for the past two years. Subscribed to four, 250g boxes per month, paid annually. I'd get the beans, vacuum pack in bags having the quantity I want for four large mugs, then freeze them. I wasn't drinking enough to keep up with the subscription, so still have quite a bit in the freezer. Besides, the subscription price has gone up ~$200 the past two years to over $920/yr.

Sey sends different coffees with each subscription. It's been fun experiencing all the different coffees, having blends to single-origin from all over the world, including some very nice Geishas.
 

Coffee makers...what works best for you?​

In short, what do you fine folks like to use the prepare your morning brew...French press, an old-school percolator, a high end espresso maker or just your basic drip machine? Whatever it is it certainly beats waiting in line for an overpriced, mediocre cup of warm brown water.
For me, it's the Sunbeam AP10 percolator from the 1950s.
I've got a Kitchenaid low rpm burr grinder that's a tank, but allows for a very course grind that works great in the Sunbeam.
My recipe is 6 level tablespoons of coffee with about 1/2 pinch of Redmond Real Salt.
My current favorite coffee is the Brazilian Peaberry from Volcanica Coffee Company.

SunbeamAP10.webp
 
A French press will give you the best brew. Followed closely by an old school percolator.

Anything pour over like a drip maker is going to lack the depth.

Full disclosure we use a drip maker every morning for ease.
 
I like a couple of cups of coffee in the morning. My wife drinks 1 cup. I don't drink coffee anymore throughout the rest of the day. We have an "Instant" brand Solo K-Cup brewer. It works great for us. No bells and whistles, just brews 8, 10, or 12 oz. It does have one of those K-Cup sized baskets that you could use to brew coffee grounds, but we don't use it. We typically get the Solimo K-Cups from Amazon...the big variety box that comes with Columbian, Bold, and French Roast. Very economical as far as K-Cup coffee pods go. And there is a nice built-in descale feature that informs you after 300 cycles. Super simple, just fill the reservoir 1/4 to 1/2 full of distilled white vinegar, top off the reservoir with water, then hold the 10 and 12 oz buttons down for 3 seconds. It runs the entire reservoir through in one shot at a lower temperature (still hot, just not boiling) at a low speed. Then run another descale mode with just water to rinse the vinegar out. Everything about this brewer is no-nonsense, which I love. It's attractive and very reliable so far.
 
I've gone full circle over the years... from a full snobbery level freshly roasted beans and manual Breville espresso machine back to Nespresso pods these days. Just got lazy and didn't feel like constantly tinkering with stuff to make sure pressure and crema was right.
 
I've gone full circle over the years... from a full snobbery level freshly roasted beans and manual Breville espresso machine back to Nespresso pods these days. Just got lazy and didn't feel like constantly tinkering with stuff to make sure pressure and crema was right.
It's not just about getting lazy. It's about prioritizing your time in ways that make the most sense for you and your life. Free time is precious. If you get off on making the best cup of coffee, go for it. But if you enjoy coffee but rather have more time for other things, then something more quick and convenient might make more sense.
 
I've gone full circle over the years... from a full snobbery level freshly roasted beans and manual Breville espresso machine back to Nespresso pods these days. Just got lazy and didn't feel like constantly tinkering with stuff to make sure pressure and crema was right.
And the fact there are easily detectable taste, body, crema differences in pod brands tells us you can get an acceptable cup from Nespresso
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom