Challenging read- Special ops soldier won’t face charges after fatally shooting civilian on his property

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again, Monday morning quarterback response.

A dusk, it clothing that made no sense. Could easily have been a terrorist forward observer for a drone mission. Actually a very feasible situation given what drones are capable of today. That camera/ smartphone might have easily have been a range finder/ laser guidance.
All true.
Or, it could be that he really worked for the cable company, doing what he was told to do and happened to cross paths with a paranoid Army Colonel who convinced himself he was under attack.
 
All true.
Or, it could be that he really worked for the cable company, doing what he was told to do and happened to cross paths with a paranoid Army Colonel who convinced himself he was under attack.
At age 16, I was delivering a pizza and apparently went to the wrong door. I was greeted with a revolver and a person who told me if I ever stopped foot on his property he would kill me.

I was internally angry at the very moment, but I knew, even at age 16 not to argue and slip away quietly into my 1971 Mercury Capri.

I would think a Russian soldier and a veteran of the Ukraine conflict would have volumes more common sense then I did at age 16.
 
I would think a Russian soldier and a veteran of the Ukraine conflict would have volumes more common sense then I did at age 16.
Well, he was found with 2 slugs in his back..... Maybe his "Mercury Capri" was too far away.

As mentioned earlier, we probably will never know what really happened that day.
 
I would think a Russian soldier and a veteran of the Ukraine conflict would have volumes more common sense then I did at age 16.

Indeed, the American stereotype is that everyone has a gun; or at least the more rural the area the higher the chances are the homeowner has several. I can't believe the worker did t think of that.
 
Well, he was found with 2 slugs in his back..... Maybe his "Mercury Capri" was too far away.

As mentioned earlier, we probably will never know what really happened that day.
Change.org reported he was shot twice in the back in the posted article. I would not repeat that he was shot twice in the back unless you had a credible source.
 
Well, he was found with 2 slugs in his back..... Maybe his "Mercury Capri" was too far away.
These Chechens are tough guys. That area of the world pumps out tons of successful UFC fighters and martial artists. I've dealt with some of these guys in a previous life and they don't care about consequences. These guys are feared more for being suicidal than actually effective. Look at their supposed losses in the Ukrainian conflict, half the time they are stealing tractors and toilets.

A man can take a few bullets to the body, angles will change during a scuffle, when it's life or death and the guy has you in a headlock or something, you will shoot anywhere.

doing what he was told to do and happened to cross paths with a paranoid Army Colonel who convinced himself he was under attack.
Was he told to become agitated and aggressive towards other people?

I wouldn't assume this Colonel was paranoid. He tried to deescalate with warnings and called the police. He was taking pictures of this guys kids after all. Imagine if he just let him continue and now you have to worry about this weirdo guy who illegally came through the southern border from some neolithic civilization thinking about your kids. Of course you would confront him...what would you do? Give him a high five?
 
“Digital evidence confirmed that Daraev was taking pictures of power poles in the direction of the residence, which was reportedly perceived by the homeowner as taking pictures of the home and homeowner’s children,”

"The confrontation escalated when Daraev reportedly became agitated and lunged at the homeowner after repeatedly refusing to leave the property," said a Sheriff's Office's news release. "The homeowner reported firing several shots in response to Daraev’s advance. Under the North Carolina Castle Doctrine, the homeowner's actions are protected, providing legal justification for using defensive force."
https://www.wunc.org/news/2024-08-13/killing-ramzan-daraev-moore-county-utility-worker-army

Not a tragic story at all. The utility worker was an idiot, became aggressive, and attacked the home owner, who had a weapon. The guy defended himself and his family, end of story. The home owner will probably have some legal bills and maybe a civil suit but maybe he can sue the utility company.

How would someone that advanced at the home owner end up with two shots in the back?

I’m starting to think if this was a civilian that shot this worker, we would have a totally different outcome. This case is being hushed out IMO.
 
How would someone that advanced at the home owner end up with two shots in the back?

I’m starting to think if this was a civilian that shot this worker, we would have a totally different outcome.
It doesn't change my mind what profession the shooter has to me at least.

We don't know the angle of the shots to the back, were they perfectly perpendicular as if the worker was walking away? Were the shots taken during a scuffle on the ground and due to the shooters hand position they were the only shots he could get off in that position? Is the family just making stuff up here?

How about someone get the autopsy report and lets see how close the muzzle blast residue is and the trajectory of the bullet wounds.

Go to reddit and search for "INSANE: Guy attacks officer with a stick... ends up taking about a dozen center mass hits before going down".
 
How would someone that advanced at the home owner end up with two shots in the back?

I’m starting to think if this was a civilian that shot this worker, we would have a totally different outcome. This case is being hushed out IMO.
It appears the two shots in the back statement is not verified, validated, or accredited by any bona fide sources.
 

Special ops soldier won’t face charges after fatally shooting civilian.​


Reading the article, a lot of different and unconnected factors led up to Special ops soldier fatally shooting a immigrant from Chechnya, who was on the Special Ops Soldier's remote rural property at dusk, taking pictures, in civilian clothes. It would later turn out that immigrant didn't speak English, and was conducting some kind of photo inspection to run fiber optics. This immigrant apparently was a prior Soldier in the Russian Army and fought in Ukraine. It should be noted the utility worker had no "company" identification, no ID whatsoever other than an international driver license. The worker's clothing of wearing only a burgundy T-shirt, black shorts and flip-flops seemed non logical for a worker at dusk in a remote area on a individual's private property.

It is important to note being a Special Ops Soldier more often than not does not equate to being a Special Forces Soldiers. This is important because a Special Forces Soldier may have been trained in numerous was to address the situation without lethal force. A Special Ops Soldier is simply a Soldier assigned to a Special Operations Unit/ Command. They may be a human resources clerk, equal opportunity advisor, mechanic, etc- and not have any specialized training in small unit tactics, etc.

Overall, a very unfortunate incident- I speculate all involved wish this encounter ended very differently.

https://www.militarytimes.com/news/...ace-charges-after-fatally-shooting-civilian/?
The soldier is a socom commander, not just some officer, the "utility worker" was working well after normal hours, wasn't in uniform, wasn't in, near or on a utility company vehicle, was from the kidnap capital of the world or at least Europe and appeared to be taking pictures of the commanders wife and kids. Also had another "utility worker" from the same country in a near by running unmarked car.
Good thing he wasted the guy instead of waiting and seeing what happens.
I dont know how military times ever ran an article thay sounds like "unstable army guy murders innocent utility worker who was just trying to do his job". MT must have gone woke.
 
Shooting someone in the back assumes they were in retreat and so is difficult for the shooter to defend. In this case that we are discussing the aggression exhibited by the so called utility worker prompted the home owner to protect his family.
 
He was taking pictures of this guys kids after all. Imagine if he just let him continue and now you have to worry about this weirdo guy who illegally came through the southern border from some neolithic civilization thinking about your kids. Of course you would confront him...what would you do? Give him a high five?
No proof at all of kiddie pics, merely an assumption. I'd bet when they looked at his phone there wasn't anything but power lines. If you have evidence otherwise, please share your source. How would anybody know how legal (or not) somebody is by looking at them.
 
The soldier is a socom commander, not just some officer, the "utility worker" was working well after normal hours, wasn't in uniform, wasn't in, near or on a utility company vehicle, was from the kidnap capital of the world or at least Europe and appeared to be taking pictures of the commanders wife and kids. Also had another "utility worker" from the same country in a near by running unmarked car.
Good thing he wasted the guy instead of waiting and seeing what happens.
I dont know how military times ever ran an article thay sounds like "unstable army guy murders innocent utility worker who was just trying to do his job". MT must have gone woke.
What Brigade does this Colonel command at SOCOM? SOCOM Commander is a four star general officer, a designated combatant commander, typically but not always an air force officer, and based at McDill AFB in Tampa.

I would appreciate a link that validated the special ops officer is a Colonel, as I seem to have missed that. Thank you.
 
It appears the two shots in the back statement is not verified, validated, or accredited by any bona fide sources.
This article mentions it.
Seems like a trigger happy individual.

Daraev’s brother says it would make no sense for Daraev to attack an armed man. The family has long argued that Daraev’s wounds -- reportedly two in the back, one in the head, and one in the hand -- suggest he was running away.

https://www.voanews.com/amp/no-charges-against-us-serviceman-in-shooting-of-chechen-man/7743454.html
 
I would say that too if I shot someone.
This is where the the medical examiners office will pay very close attention and go into detail during the autopsy and investigation. If there was any shred of evidence that this guy just plainly shot the guy in the back and made up a lie it would be uncovered.

This isn't the 50's where you tell the police "ask the dead guy what happened" and the problem goes away. The tech and knowledge modern county medical examiners have is pretty amazing. Look at the old Forensics Files episodes from the late 90s - 00s, they performed miracles in those labs and can do even more now. The size of the gunshot residue, if any, on the assailant would be an easy tell how close the shot was.

No proof at all of kiddie pics, merely an assumption. I'd bet when they looked at his phone there wasn't anything but power lines. If you have evidence otherwise, please share your source.
"The initial 911 call to the Sheriff's Office was made by the homeowner's wife at 8:12 PM. During the call, she stated that a suspicious person was observed on her property taking photographs of the house and children, and that her husband had approached the individual to speak with them. She noted that there was an apparent language barrier, and that the person was acting aggressively. The second call, which was more exigent, was made at 8:25 PM. At one point during the calls, the caller could be heard pleading for expedited law enforcement response at the request of her husband, who could be heard yelling to her in the background. She secured a rifle during one of the calls, reflecting the perceived level of threat. The shooting allegedly took place shortly after the second call, just prior to deputies arriving on scene."

"Efforts to access Daraev’s cellular phone continue in effort to fully understand his activities and the nature of any photographs taken. Some images Daraev uploaded to a shared directory have been obtained, and analysis is ongoing. Given the unique circumstances of the incident, the sheriff’s office has voluntarily kept all case materials accessible to the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Army Criminal Investigation Division throughout the investigation."

https://www.facebook.com/MCSheriffOffice/ see 8/12 post

At the 2:10 mark of the second audio recording, the wife states pictures are being taken of the children. I doubt she made this up in the heat of the moment as a future defense.

https://www.thepilot.com/news/audio...cle_7d22432c-1e96-11ef-a4af-b720a4ec2d30.html

“He's from Chechnya. He came up on our poverty line. My kids are in the backyard," the caller said. "He's taking pictures of our property. My husband is, he's a military specialist. He's trained and he knows what he's doing, but I really need some police presence here."

"He's taking pictures of your property?" the dispatcher asked.

"Of our children, of our property," the caller said.

How would anybody know how legal (or not) somebody is by looking at them.
Well maybe if they are screaming "derka! derka! derka!" at you while being aggressive and trespassing on your property?
 
This is where the the medical examiners office will pay very close attention and go into detail during the autopsy and investigation. If there was any shred of evidence that this guy just plainly shot the guy in the back and made up a lie it would be uncovered.
These are small counties in the South. How many people did Alex Murdaugh kill before he was even brought up on charges. In fact, the only way he was finally even looked into is after too many they finally brought in the medical examiner from Charleston County and they refused to agree with the original findings.

Fun fact - this shooting took place in Moore County. You may recall a couple years ago someone was running around shooting up power substations and whole communities were without power for weeks. Same County.

Not saying he did or didn't, but things work differently in these places.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom