Well, I change out the old, cracked, hose for the PCV and what I think is a sort of return hose (goes from the air filter to the engine, right next to the PCV), and changed out the oil for Valvoline ML NG 10w-40, and the consumption has decreased enormously.
Now I only see oil burning if the car has been running for a little while (over thirty minutes). I see smoke only on hard acceleration, especially after idling for a bit. I still haven't gotten a new PCV valve (I know, tsk, tsk), so I'm hoping that might still be the culprit.