just how much benefit would there be if i were to siphon out my brake and p/s reservoirs and put new in? i only have 29500 miles should it be done or is it unnecessary
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
brake and p/s siphon
- Thread starter swirlparanoid
- Start date
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
Personally, if you start doing the siphon/refill routine now.. I believe it'll help keep your fluids lasting easily to 100k.
In the brake reservoir the fluid really has no movement with out bleeding.
It will not circulate into the system. I suppose its good to have fresh brake fluid sitting in there if or when you do bleed.
Don't mix these fluids with a drippy turkey baster.
The P/S will benifit from this method and it would be good to do this about five times & observe how that oil cleans up.
It will not circulate into the system. I suppose its good to have fresh brake fluid sitting in there if or when you do bleed.
Don't mix these fluids with a drippy turkey baster.
The P/S will benifit from this method and it would be good to do this about five times & observe how that oil cleans up.
Originally Posted By: willix
In the brake reservoir the fluid really has no movement with out bleeding.
It will not circulate into the system. I suppose its good to have fresh brake fluid sitting in there if or when you do bleed.
Don't mix these fluids with a drippy turkey baster.
The P/S will benifit from this method and it would be good to do this about five times & observe how that oil cleans up.
I have done the turkey baster method for years, and brake fluid will circulate slowely through the system. Also it works well for the PS pump as well. Every OC I do both, and find it is an effective way to service these units.
In the brake reservoir the fluid really has no movement with out bleeding.
It will not circulate into the system. I suppose its good to have fresh brake fluid sitting in there if or when you do bleed.
Don't mix these fluids with a drippy turkey baster.
The P/S will benifit from this method and it would be good to do this about five times & observe how that oil cleans up.
I have done the turkey baster method for years, and brake fluid will circulate slowely through the system. Also it works well for the PS pump as well. Every OC I do both, and find it is an effective way to service these units.
As far as the brake fluid goes it needs to be FLUSHED, just replacing the fluid in the resovior doesn't really do anything. Honda recomends every 3 years as do many other companies.
Brake lines do not have a return line so the fluid is not cycled like the coolant system or the trans fluid system. The fluid in the lines pretty much just hangs out there.
I just bought a brake bleeder to do some vehicles in the family.
As for the power steering it is a cycled system as far as I understand and adding fluid should help.
Brake lines do not have a return line so the fluid is not cycled like the coolant system or the trans fluid system. The fluid in the lines pretty much just hangs out there.
I just bought a brake bleeder to do some vehicles in the family.
As for the power steering it is a cycled system as far as I understand and adding fluid should help.
No, brake fluid just doesn't hang there. So, there is definitely a benefit to siphon/refilling the master cylinder. The BF doesn't circulate in a loop, but it definitely travels back and forth throughout the entire system constantly mixing.
I prefer yearly brake bleeds. And, when lazy, I wouldn't go more than 2 years.
Just doing what any manufacturer says doesn't guaranty optimum life. Most automaker recommendations are border line abusive and can cause issues for anyone that keeps vehicles longer than a car payment.
A siphon/refill of the PSF at every oil change is a good start. Because said vehicle has 30k miles, I consider several siphon/refills over several days to get some fresh fluid in there, and then continue with some time or mileage based interval.
I prefer yearly brake bleeds. And, when lazy, I wouldn't go more than 2 years.
Just doing what any manufacturer says doesn't guaranty optimum life. Most automaker recommendations are border line abusive and can cause issues for anyone that keeps vehicles longer than a car payment.
A siphon/refill of the PSF at every oil change is a good start. Because said vehicle has 30k miles, I consider several siphon/refills over several days to get some fresh fluid in there, and then continue with some time or mileage based interval.
You guys can debate this forever but brake fluid does circulate a little every time you apply the brakes.
Replacing the brake fluid in the brake reservoir does not replace a good pressure bleed but it sure helps.
So long as you are careful and don’t accidentally apply the brakes while the brake reservoir is empty, replacing your brake fluid at least once a year is very good for your brake system.
Guess every one here knows that whatever you use to remove the brake fluid from the brake reservoir needs to be new or at least to never have come in contact with any oil. Brake fluid is a unique nasty fluid and will ruin paint and some plastics.
Replacing the brake fluid in the brake reservoir does not replace a good pressure bleed but it sure helps.
So long as you are careful and don’t accidentally apply the brakes while the brake reservoir is empty, replacing your brake fluid at least once a year is very good for your brake system.
Guess every one here knows that whatever you use to remove the brake fluid from the brake reservoir needs to be new or at least to never have come in contact with any oil. Brake fluid is a unique nasty fluid and will ruin paint and some plastics.
No need to debate anything, I'm sure you guys know more than me. I just never thought of brake fluid ever returning to the master cylinder. Still don't really understand how it does that but I'll take your word for it.
Even if it does cycle I would still think that it would take a long time to get new fluid to the calipers. In my opinion changing the resovoir fluid is almost a waste of time and fluid, just flush regularly. A flush is easy to do so no reason not to do one every year or two.
Even if it does cycle I would still think that it would take a long time to get new fluid to the calipers. In my opinion changing the resovoir fluid is almost a waste of time and fluid, just flush regularly. A flush is easy to do so no reason not to do one every year or two.
Think of brake fluid circulation as adding food coloring to a container of water. It all wants to become equal, so it slowly mixes until it becomes the same.
It certainly won't get fresh fluid through quickly, and isn't a substitute for a bleed. However, once the system is bled with clean fluid, it can help keep it fresh for longer.
It certainly won't get fresh fluid through quickly, and isn't a substitute for a bleed. However, once the system is bled with clean fluid, it can help keep it fresh for longer.
An explanation isn't simple, but there is something like a pressure on an area with a higher concentration to move to an area with lower concentration in the same material. Cigarette smoke in one room will find its way to adjacent rooms even with no fans blowing it. The contaminants in the fluid will gradually want to move to the clean fluid and this will have a domino effect from the reservoir to the brake as each drop (on the reservoir side) gets a little cleaner than the drop next to it (on the brake side) every time the brake is applied.
Here is a quote from a couple of years ago:
Quote:
Yes. There is a lot of movement.
Some more than others, and an ABS system isn't certain.
At the shop we have performed and recommended turkey baster type flushes for people with economic restrictions. It usually helps or fixes some problems, and is certainly good maintainance.
My latest experience was a Chevy work truck. We had the owner suck out his master cyl and clean it, then refill with fresh fluid every couple of days. It would get black rapidly, then started to clear up, and his rear brakes started working properly again.
Of course bleeding the system is faster and better. But we have to deal with people with no money and broken off rusted bleeders.
I turkey baster my personal vehicles as a regular maintainance procedure
-quick and clean for PS and brakes.
Here is a quote from a couple of years ago:
Quote:
Yes. There is a lot of movement.
Some more than others, and an ABS system isn't certain.
At the shop we have performed and recommended turkey baster type flushes for people with economic restrictions. It usually helps or fixes some problems, and is certainly good maintainance.
My latest experience was a Chevy work truck. We had the owner suck out his master cyl and clean it, then refill with fresh fluid every couple of days. It would get black rapidly, then started to clear up, and his rear brakes started working properly again.
Of course bleeding the system is faster and better. But we have to deal with people with no money and broken off rusted bleeders.
I turkey baster my personal vehicles as a regular maintainance procedure
-quick and clean for PS and brakes.
Brake fluid does not circulate. Its a one way hydraulic system. It has no return circuit. It just deadheads.
Originally Posted By: rslifkin
Think of brake fluid circulation as adding food coloring to a container of water. It all wants to become equal, so it slowly mixes until it becomes the same.
It certainly won't get fresh fluid through quickly, and isn't a substitute for a bleed. However, once the system is bled with clean fluid, it can help keep it fresh for longer.
That all sounds good but the fact is it deadheads at the reservoir.
It would be a more accurate analogy -a plugged up toilet.
Think of brake fluid circulation as adding food coloring to a container of water. It all wants to become equal, so it slowly mixes until it becomes the same.
It certainly won't get fresh fluid through quickly, and isn't a substitute for a bleed. However, once the system is bled with clean fluid, it can help keep it fresh for longer.
That all sounds good but the fact is it deadheads at the reservoir.
It would be a more accurate analogy -a plugged up toilet.
Last edited:
The ABS unit functions pretty much the same the master cylinder only its far away from the reservoir.
It just circulates within itself. It has its own bleeder valves.
The defect in the theory is that you need to be using the brakes for a little drifting clean fluid to mix with a little drifting contaminated fluid.
Smart drivers use less braking. How often is the ABS in in terms of seconds?
It just circulates within itself. It has its own bleeder valves.
The defect in the theory is that you need to be using the brakes for a little drifting clean fluid to mix with a little drifting contaminated fluid.
Smart drivers use less braking. How often is the ABS in in terms of seconds?
Originally Posted By: willix
...
That all sounds good but the fact is it deadheads at the reservoir.
It would be a more accurate analogy -a plugged up toilet.
not really. every time you push on the brake pedal a bolus of fresh (master cylinder reservoir mixture) is injected into the brake tubes. The injection bolus plus surface friction of the tubing enhances mixing and the contamination particles will diffuse into the fresher mixture. Releasing the brakes pushes some of the mix back into the reservoir, where it mixes/ diffuses with the fresher fluid.
I wouldn't call this a circulation either; however, the fluid is mixing.
...
That all sounds good but the fact is it deadheads at the reservoir.
It would be a more accurate analogy -a plugged up toilet.
not really. every time you push on the brake pedal a bolus of fresh (master cylinder reservoir mixture) is injected into the brake tubes. The injection bolus plus surface friction of the tubing enhances mixing and the contamination particles will diffuse into the fresher mixture. Releasing the brakes pushes some of the mix back into the reservoir, where it mixes/ diffuses with the fresher fluid.
I wouldn't call this a circulation either; however, the fluid is mixing.
Isn't hydralic fluid non-compressable? So when you apply the brakes and a small amount of fluid pushes against the fluid in the lines I don't see how it "mixes". I understand that the fluid might "mix" a little but I would think this would be minimal?
Also if this fluid is "mixing" and fluid from all the way down by the caliper is somehow getting back to the master wouldn't the brake system also self bleed air out?
I'm not arguing, just trying to learn something here but from what I know about the properties of hydralic brake fluid it doesn't mix well.
I have a jug of brake fluid in the garage, is there something I can mix with half the jug to make it "old fluid" and then pour some new on top and see what happens? Food coloring or something else?
Also if this fluid is "mixing" and fluid from all the way down by the caliper is somehow getting back to the master wouldn't the brake system also self bleed air out?
I'm not arguing, just trying to learn something here but from what I know about the properties of hydralic brake fluid it doesn't mix well.
I have a jug of brake fluid in the garage, is there something I can mix with half the jug to make it "old fluid" and then pour some new on top and see what happens? Food coloring or something else?
Originally Posted By: scott37300
Isn't hydralic fluid non-compressable? So when you apply the brakes and a small amount of fluid pushes against the fluid in the lines I don't see how it "mixes". I understand that the fluid might "mix" a little but I would think this would be minimal?
...
yes. Imagine that the brake system is long tube with fluid filled balloons on each end. You squeeze one end, the balloon on the other end expands. You release the pressure, a bit comes back and mixes.
As far as air self bleeding out, it will more likely just find a local high spot in the tube and sit there.
Isn't hydralic fluid non-compressable? So when you apply the brakes and a small amount of fluid pushes against the fluid in the lines I don't see how it "mixes". I understand that the fluid might "mix" a little but I would think this would be minimal?
...
yes. Imagine that the brake system is long tube with fluid filled balloons on each end. You squeeze one end, the balloon on the other end expands. You release the pressure, a bit comes back and mixes.
As far as air self bleeding out, it will more likely just find a local high spot in the tube and sit there.
It is a good idea to TB the fluids.
No movement in the brake system? Nonsense. It does not move like PS systems, but it certainly will migrate.
Sure, not as good as a real bleed, but for almost zero trouble, it is well worth doing as maintenance.
No movement in the brake system? Nonsense. It does not move like PS systems, but it certainly will migrate.
Sure, not as good as a real bleed, but for almost zero trouble, it is well worth doing as maintenance.
A yearly ritual for me. The only time I flush brakes id when changing pads and I just use the two people method.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
Similar threads
- Replies
- 33
- Views
- 1K
- Replies
- 5
- Views
- 592
