ran it with the cap off, looked like a weak clockwise whirlpool. Once temp hit about 205F the fans came on and the thermostat opened, it looked more like a river/whirlpool after that. I'm wondering if the original thermostat went bad, and the replacement is crap because it's a duralast, the date on it is 6/2018...I looked on rockauto and the aisin O.E one is supposed to open at 180F. I ordered the aisin from rockauto, guess I'll switch it again and see. I did boil the original thermostat and it opened about 1/4 of an inch, the spring wouldn't collapse any more than that so confirmed the original was a big issue, if not THE issue. This duralast is probably trash, I'm reading issues from other boards with duralast thermostats not opening until 205-210.
The side of the housing says 82C, the old googles says that is 179.6F, so 180. (this is the original one I pulled)
This is at boiling temp, I took it out and immediately took a photo...from the photos online I have seen, that large spring should collapse much farther than that, the opening here doesn't seem large enough to allow efficient circulation which would explain why it would get 3/4 up the gauge then go back to normal running the heater on full blast, it was allowing SOME, just enough to not completely overheat. I'm reading that these duralast ones aren't opening until a little over 200. If Lexus designed them to open at 180, they did that for a reason.
I could see how the duralast one not opening until at least 200 would mimic these same symptoms, the thermostat opens when the coolant is already too hot per manufacturer spec, by the time it circulates to cool it gets a little below 200 and closes again...never getting down to the 180 lexus calls for before closing, thus not allowing the coolant to get cool enough. I'm not super knowledgeable here but that's how it makes sense in my mind. This thermostat looks partially open to me, what do you think?
I tried to shove a screwdriver in the opening when it was "open" to pry it open and see if it could open more, it did, then broke lol. I guess I could install this housing without a thermostat and see if it repeats the issue while waiting on the aisin one to come next week, not sure what a lack of a thermostat would do to emissions components or other things though, might get the "open loop" code