COSTCO batteries are like this nowadays. I had one Interstate from them in March, the sticker was March 2023. I always put them on a charger before installing. It would go down to 12.58V next morning. I went back and replaced it with another one. The same effect. OK, may be a fluke, a funny batch. I put back a 7 year old battery that still holds above 12.65 for 5 days. I wait for a couple of months, I go back to COSTCO in July 2023. Get another new battery, stcker is July 2023. It gives me 12.60V in situ. So, I got a Duralast Gold from the Zone. I do not know who is the mfg, it is a flat top, regular flooded, Made in Korea. So far it acts like a new battery.
There is always a reason why something is dramatically cheaper. And it is not always a good reason.