In a perfect world, maybe we wouldn't need all that protection running.
I've installed and run spybotSD in multiple computers. SAS has never found anything in those systems. So, I don't see it as worthless. It is free and has a good immunization that isn't a resource hog. Always pair it up with spyblaster.
Any AV program is a must these days. Sorry, not everyone has a hardware firewall, linux...... and most enjoy downloading every possible email, music, video, picture, visiting questionable websites........ The typical user doesn't have common sense.
If you're a Network Admin and don't believe in protection, then I wouldn't hire you. It is up to you to assume the user is a fool, since most are. No wonder why so many companies have issues and poor security! Too much reliance on '1' method.
Many programs do not waste resources on a decently powered PC. My 512mb P3-1400mhz Via'd(chip/graphics/sound) has no problem running with an AV program, firewall, and antispy in the background. No speed issues here.
My recommendation for everyone:
Any AV program. Avast, AVG, and Antivir are 3 FREE to use.
Any antispy program. AVG has it built in the free 8.0 now.
Enabled firewall, whether Vista/XP or Comodo, zonealarm.....
Everyone forgets Opendns. I find that a simple mistype leading to a questionable website can hose a system. Opendns is so easy to use.
All available updates, especially if running anything from MS. Regular automated/manual scans/updates/habits with the software you choose is also a must.
Any user can hose any browser. I have no issues with IE. Stick with the latest one with all updates. Is Firefox, without noscript, any better? Doubt it! And, as any user base with a program, like an alternative browser, grows larger, more will attack it.
The other week, I found an interesting virus on a PC that none of the major AV programs detected. Even after submitting it, only 3 of 30 would pick it up now. Its a scary world. Protect yourself, update, and scan regularly. Competitor scans should also be considered, regardless of what your front line protection is.
http://www.security-ops.eu.tt/