I'm due for an oil change and with the arctic temps here to stay, would it be better for me to go with Durablend 5w20 or Shell 5w30 conventional that I have in my stash for colder starts and temps?
You should be using a full synthetic oil, as the pour point is much lower than for the same given weight in a conventional or synthetic blend oil. You might even consider a 0W oil.
I'm sure you've seen the youtube video that M1 put out, pretty enlightening.