I like it so far. I think the comparisons to sports cars and calling it a fail because it isn't one, betrays either a misunderstanding of what the Civic was always intended as (Honda's version of the "people's car"), or not understanding that its very sporty look (to me anyway) is meant to improve mileage - not turn it into a Corvette. It states in the article that Honda is placing a big emphasis on improving mileage with the 2012 model, and that body design - which will be shared across all sub-models, one of which will be a hybrid - is one component of that. Its not meant, even in the SI flavor, to make it a sports car - though it'll probably be well received by the tuner crowd and have generous aftermarket upgrades available in time.
Those looking for an off the floor sports car should be looking at those cars that are billed as sports cars rather than knock something for not being what it was never intended to be. If you want to make a just comparison, then a hybrid like the Prius or sedan like the Corolla would be a little fairer (not to single out Toyota, these are just better comparative examples that come to mind).
JMO.
-Spyder