Assuming oil pressure is normal, I'd probably use Quaker State Defy 5w30, only because I'm a skeptic about the Zn/P level in API SN rated oil. I notice the datasheets on rated oil usually has near the limit on phosphorus, which suggests to me they'd like to use more if they could.
With the age of the engine, a high mileage oil might help keep the seals in shape. But I don't know how effective that stuff really is.
I could also happily use Valvoline or Pennzoil's conventionals, not for any great reason but just because I have in the past.