I love my little Cavalier. It may be lacking a bit on power (2.2 engine with an automatic transmission will do that), but in terms of looks, there are few other things out there that beat it. The extra .4 liters of displacement give it more torque than the Corolla I used to drive, and it's quite noticeable. With just front and rear strut bars, it handles much better than any other "cheap" car I've driven, though the Corolla always felt like a boat.
EDIT: Get a Cobalt. Or the new Focus.