Could be a variance in the temperature sensor or slight variance or different thermostats. I would get my hands on a laser pointed infrared electronic thermometer gun they sell at hardware stores. Go for a drive, stop where it's safe, pop the hood and take a reading at the thermostat housing. Repeat with the other car. Compare the gage to the temp gun reading to verify. If everything checks out, I would verify the cooling fan is working and consider putting in a new 180 deg thermostat in the car that is at 200 deg.