Switch from Mobil 1 to Honda Genuine??

Status
Not open for further replies.
I see what you guys are saying about today's high quality conventional oils, and I have seen how good Honda used oil analysis are on just about anything. But like the OP said, aren't there advantages to synthetic other than merely extending the OCI? Why can't he just run a top notch oil for a relatively short OCI if he pleases?
 
Last edited:
Just another data point... I recently switched from Honda dealer maintenance on my '08 Odyssey to Plain Jane Mobil 1, and have gone from changing oil at 30% of the maintenance minder to 5%. Form me, that is a move from 5,000 miles to 6,500.

I think that in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't really matter what you choose to do, as others have said. Here's my take:

1. There is no question that Mobil 1 is an absolutely excellent, time-tested synthetic.

2. While the Honda oil is fine, it can come from anywhere and I am pretty sure is a conventional oil, plus it is nowhere near as "available" as M1, which Walmart dishes out all day long.

My vote is for M1 or PU or Edge (which I am using in a high mileage v6 acura).

Good luck!
 
LT4, with the 10k OCI on the Civic, do you find you need to add make up oil?
I'm about to go beyond the MM for the first time and do a 10k OCI.
 
Last edited:
If you look at Mobil 5000 and the voa of Honda they are not the same. Not at all. So that leaves you with knowing the Honda oil is made by Mobil but not something you can go out and duplicate off the shelf. Same too the idea the new COP oil is going to be Motorcraft in a new bottle might not be the case either. Honda will make the oil that makes them the most money and the cars running till 60,000 or 5 years which ever comes first. Nothing means more than profit the oil will be made with that being the most important item.
34.gif

Originally Posted By: Gurney
A couple of small points, tpatt: When your owner's manual was written, "Honda Motor Oil" (meaning the bottled product sold by your Honda dealer) was, in fact, Mobil Clean 5000. It was, and still is, a conventional oil. (And a pretty good one, too. See http://www.pqiamerica.com/testresults3a.html.)

Recently, as you may know, Honda turned to ConocoPhillips (COP) for its bottled and bulk oil products. COP also happens to be Ford Motor Company's supplier for Motorcraft 5W-20 weight motor oil. In that weight, MC is a semi-synthetic oil. I (and a few others who trade COP) believe it's unlikely that COP will create another (different) bulk or bottled 5W-20 weight product just for HMC, which means that Honda customers who purchase "Honda Motor Oil" in the future will, in fact, be buying COP's semi-synthetic Motorcraft oil sold under a Honda label. This will work out well for the customer: whereas before you would have been buying XOM's conventional 5W-20 weight oil, now you'll be buying COP's 5W-20 semi-synthetic. It might be a bargain.

Of course, you can purchase the exact same product already, and likely save a few dollars more while you're at it, simply by buying Motorcraft 5W-20 oil at WalMart.

In any case, I agree with Bill in Utah that it really doesn't matter what you run in a Honda Civic (said the guy who's owned all sorts of Hondas). With 5K oil changes, your's will last forever. I also agree with you that the fun part of any oil change is doing it yourself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom