Originally Posted By: engineerscott
Originally Posted By: boraticus
The only thing I've actually seen a gasoline fuel additive clean is my wallet. I've yet to see any dramatic or conclusive evidence that any of the additives that I've tried for gasoline engines did anything.
I in general agree with this with one exception. I have seen Chevron Techron make an engine go from surging/sputtering/refusing to idle to running smoothly in a remarkably short time. So fast that I wonder if perhaps what was going on was that ethanol/water had fallen out of solution in the fuel and maybe the techron was causing the fuel to re-absorb the water. It's possible. However, whatever the actual mechanism I have seen Techron make an engine go from running badly to running smoothly on several occasions. I've never seen similar results from other injector/carb cleaner additives. That said, I don't use Techron on a regular basis. I may run a bottle through a tank of gas in one of our cars once in a blue moon, and I only use it on OPE when I've got something that is running poorly.
The poor running conditions does sound like water in the fuel. Putting enough alcohol into the fuel to absorb it will help move it through the fuel system. That's for sure.
Fuel injection systems might benefit from the occasional cleaner being run through them. I have never seen any advantage from running an additive through a carbureted engine and particularly in OPE.
Below is the MSDS data for Techron. Not that naptha is the primary ingredient as it is with most other additives.
2. COMPOSITION/INFORMATION ON INGREDIENTS ______________________________________________________________________
100.0 % CHEVRON TECHRON Concentrate CONTAINING
COMPONENTS SOLVENTS INCLUDING:
AMOUNT
> 20.00%
LIMIT/QTY
AGENCY/TYPE
NA
ACGIH TWA OSHA PEL
SOLVENT NAPHTHA, LT. AROMATIC Chemical Name: SOLVENT NAPHTHA, LIGHT AROMATIC
CAS64742956
STODDARD SOLVENT Chemical Name: STODDARD SOLVENT CAS8052413
NONE
100 ppm 2900 mg/m3
HYDROTREATED, DISTILLATE, LT.
Chemical Name: DISTILLATES, HYDROTREATED CAS64742478
INCLUDING TRIMETHYLBENZENE-1,2,4
LIGHT NONE
25 ppm
100 ppm 150 ppm 100 ppm 100 LBS
50 ppm 50 ppm 5,000 LBS
NA
ACGIH TWA
ACGIH TWA ACGIH STEL OSHA PEL CERCLA 302.4 RQ
ACGIH TWA OSHA PEL CERCLA 302.4 RQ
Name: BENZENE, 1,2,4, TRIMETHYL < 8.00%
XYLENE Chemical CAS1330207 < 3.55%
CUMENE Chemical Name: BENZENE, (1-METHYLETHYL)- CAS98828 < 1.50%
Chemical CAS95636
Name: BENZENE, DIMETHYL-
COMPOSITION COMMENT: All the components of this material are on the Toxic Substances Control Act Chemical Substances Inventory.