I don't know what Terry would say about this particular Dodge engine, but I would think he'd at least have to entertain the notion that it's just a bad combination of an engine with a tendency to accumulate moisture and an oil with the same peculiar habit.
Molakule mentioned earlier in this thread that he believed (based on the info available in the thread) that the engine has a rusting problem. That makes sense...
My problem with Redline is that it just seems like a bad return on one's investment. I think that Mobil 1 and Amsoil are too, but RL seems to turn in the worst UOA's of the three, and it costs the most.
We don't get enough specifics from those presumably in the know to justify or explain what we see in the typical Redline UOA. Why must it be so clandestine, so esoteric? I'm a firm believer in the old adage that if you cannot explain something in layman's terms, you don't understand it.
So with that said, for my part I must trust the wear metal counts in the UOA's as the best indication of whether the engine is being protected--or not.
Dan