Pennzoil Platinum 5w-30

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 27, 2010
Messages
133
Location
Iowa
Trying PP for the first time in my 2005 Silverado 5.3. Just under 5000 on the motor as it was replaced under warranty. After a couple short changes with conventional oil it's time for synthetic. Curious to see if I'll see a difference in oil pressure with the PP over regular oil.

I've never used PP before. Sure had a different smell than M1 syn or most oils for that matter.
 
You shouldn't be disappointed. Look at some of the used oil analysis on it. Probably one of the most consistently good oils out there, (that doesn't cost an arm and a leg).
 
It was the used oil analysis on this site that got me considering it. Always used M1 for Syns before except for a short stint with Amsoil. Also thinking I might use the PP in my wifes '11 Nox with the 2.4 DI engine, but still undecided there.
 
what happened to your original motor and how many miles were on it? Also did GM give you any problems getting them to put a motor in?
was it a new motor or rebuilt?
 
I got it as a certified used with 42k. Started ticking. At first dealer wanted to call it piston slap or carbon buildup. They threw some bg44 in it which did nothing. It eventually grew to a tick and knock and the dealer agreed it was worse so tore motor down. Found cam wear and 3 pistons had worn through the skirting.

Not really sure what caused the damage. Visually the truck was well cared for before I bought it. Overheated, bad oil, who knows.

Other than several trips and complaints to dealer before tear down it went fine. To my knowledge GM didn't fight replacing it. It's a GM reman new motor. As new as I could get for an 05. It came as a long block including sheet metal.
 
Originally Posted By: tsduke
Trying PP for the first time in my 2005 Silverado 5.3. Just under 5000 on the motor as it was replaced under warranty. After a couple short changes with conventional oil it's time for synthetic. Curious to see if I'll see a difference in oil pressure with the PP over regular oil.

I've never used PP before. Sure had a different smell than M1 syn or most oils for that matter.


You won't be disappointed in your oil choice...PP is a great oil!
 
good to hear that gm honors their warrantee the gm remanufactured engines are usually good units i believe they are balanced also (some other engines are not)
we see a fair share of those engines here for rebuilds... Did they ask for oil change proof?
Also was the dealer "happy" to do it? (some dont like it because GM puts a time limit on the work and only pays for the time they allow...
Was the work done professional or was it done to cut corners i am just curious because i am in the engine business and i see some real screw ups
By the way pp is a great oil
 
Everyone I asked about the GM reman said it was as good as new if not better because it includes any updates to the motor.

They did not ask for proof of oil change, but the service advisor new I had it changed a couple times at their quick lube plus a couple of my own changes.(trying to clean out the motor) So in 8000 since I bought it, it had 4 changes, 2 they would have record of. More than enough. btw, the noises sounded worse with M1 vs conventional.

It a few visits to the dealer over those 8000 miles to get them to treat it as a serious isse, but once the decided it needed tore down it went ok. They actually only tore down the top end at first think it was the cam, but saw that the cam may have only been source of the tick and not the knock, so the rest the way down it went. In all, they had it 10 days. Diagnosing, tear down, talking with GM powertrain, etc.

I was very happy with the tech's work. Nothing under the hood looked out of place. Everthing was cleaned, straps back in place. It looked just like it did, except for a clean aluminum block.
 
That's good to know as I kick around the idea of getting a Silverado 1500. Looks like GM might be trying to stay in business this time around.
 
thats nice to know i have seen a couple of bad jobs done in various shops...here in this shop it gets done correctly or it will be done again
 
when a company fixes a problem on its own that is a company i will buy from again....When they refuse to fix it and you wind up winning a lemon law lawsuit thats good too...hehe
then you get a brand new car and all sorts of goos stuff
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom