oil pan/filter magnet

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 29, 2006
Messages
115
Location
Indiana, USA
I searched and found nothing on this.

Is it a good idea to install a magnet on the outside of the oil pan, near the drain plug?

I read somewhere that it is better to install it on the oil filter, but I see two potential problems with this. First, if installed on the side of the filter, it could cause premature goo buildup on the filtering media, restricting flow and engaging the bi-pass valve prematurely. If installed on the bottom of the filter it could directly interfere with the function of the bi-pass valve since most of it's components are probably Ferrous.
So magnet or not? And where?
Thanks
 
Why not just get a magnetic drain plug.
A magnet near the drain plug would work, but you'd
have to remove it each time you drained the oil;
that's easy to forget and a PIA.
 
well, not only remove it, the pan will probably get magnetized so you would need to wipe the area to clear metallic debris. I just put a few strong magnets around the filter.
Alternatively, epoxy glue a magnet to the drain plug it's not one there already
 
The problem I see with putting a magnet on the pan itself...you might not be able to get all of the metal shavings out.

If you remove the magnet and then go to drain the oil then you run the risk that not all of the shavings will flow out. Maybe there won't be enough turbulence to move them...maybe they'll "stick" to the bottom of the pan. Either way you could get a wad of metal shavings sitting there waiting to clog your pick-up screen.

Drain plug or filter seem like the best options to me.
 
I have used magnets on the outside of a filter and cut them apart to see what was there. I found a very fine fur where the magnet was located. Filtering action is outside to inside on an oil filter and clogging of any kind should not be an issue. If anything, the magnet might make the filter clog less as material is being kept from going through the filter media.
 
so something like filtermag.com or some magnetic band that fits over the oil filter be really good to invest in and using?!

it seems like i need to order one for my jeep.
 
Quote:



First, if installed on the side of the filter, it could cause premature goo buildup on the filtering media, restricting flow and engaging the bi-pass valve prematurely. If installed on the bottom of the filter it could directly interfere with the function of the bi-pass valve since most of it's components are probably Ferrous.
So magnet or not? And where?
Thanks



You may have a point about the bottom of the filter
dunno.gif
but I see no problem with putting it on the side. If it causes something to gunk up too much, the magnet is not your main concern.
 
i asked my mechanic friends about this. Having a magnet on the oil pan and such and they said well it wouldn't hurt if you try it.

So i ended up going to radio shack to pay about $1.79 or less for two lil bitty 1/8th inch size rare earth magnet. I put one on the bottom of the oil pan and the other on the side of the oil filter.

I just might order one from filter mag though very soon so i have more surface area.
 
Quote:


magnetic drain plug at your local autparts store, $4.




Yes , this will work . However ......


In days of olde , when knights were bold ..... well , alright , call this a beater school of maintenance - magnet trick #1 .

Go to your friendly aftermarket stereo store/installer and ask if you can go thru the trash where they throw all the old speakers out .

Get yourself some kind of speaker magnet that will fit on some kind of flat wall "near" the drain plug area - and not create some other kind of problem . (Side or backside is safer but bottom (protected) is fine - if you have grd clearance).
Remove the magnet from the speaker and install on the clean oil pan surface you have carefully selected .

When time comes to change your very warm to hot oil (important) remove the magnet and with a suitable soft and very, blunt object LIGHTLY rap the "hot" pan in various locations until some test object held close indicates the magnetized pan is no longer magnetic - or at least barely so .
(A large enough (full pan lenght or width is fine) piece of soft wood will keep those with less experience out of trouble).
All you want to accomplish here is to lightly "vibrate" the HOT pan repeatably , - enough to lose most of its magnetism .
Wiggle the vehicle to slosh the pan just a little bit - gently - you just want a small amount of movement in the pan here - not big splashes - doesn't take much push on the vehicle .


Now drain your fluid .


I say fluid , because this can be even more useful on a steel transmission pan esp one with OEM non-filtration filtration .
laugh.gif


If you are fortunate enough to have a high clearance vehicle with a large transmission pan such as a Ford F250
wink.gif
thumbsup.gif
you can go to town on this - to the point of barely being able to remove the magnetic w/o damaging yourself or the vehicle .

Up to that point more or several is generally better .

Lets cover one common nay say on this .

Lets say you are in a hurry and don't fully demagnitize the pan before drain so that not all or even very little of the magnetic material flows out .


Ok , ......think , people , think .... sooooo what !
If the pans still "that" magnetic the stuffs not going anywhere harmful and you are going to reinstall the magnet before filling anyway .


If people really knew just how much magnetic material remained behind on ATs with internal magnets .... including on all or part of the pan when they do their partial drains .....


Anyway , if you leave a big one on for a while and then remove the pan come service time you will not believe what your magnet pulled out and held on your magnetic transmission pan - even compared to internal factory magnets .


This is all good .
smile.gif


One possible downside - it can become something of a disease .

You know you got it bad when you start attaching magnets to things like iron master cylinders
laugh.gif
and trying to figure out how you can secure one in your power steering pump reservoir w/o messing something up .
grin.gif


For some , the most interesting uses involve coolant and cooling systems - correctly configured - strange but wonderful things can happen given enough time .
shocked.gif
cool.gif
blush.gif


offtopic.gif

Without a doubt , Sarge and his Dad are the real deal - any pictures of Mom ?
cheers.gif
patriot.gif
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom