I've had quite a few bikes, too. Old stuff, new stuff, abused stuff, stuff in near-mint condition. I've tried almost every oil out there. You know what? I don't like Castrol or Valvolene. I like Silkolene, Motul, and either Rotella or the Chevron Delo (although the new stuff w/moly is a no-no). I *really* like Amsoil for bikes. Mobil 1 for bikes is also great, but it's SOOOO expensive. We are talking 2-3x as expensive as the Amsoil.
As for "I put synthetic oil in my bike and it ", well, that might be true but I find it extremely hard to believe that it's causal rather than coincidental.