Jay, your cat, especially young ones, wants company more than toys.
Until he is about 2 years old, you need to play a lot with him in order him to be a happy and solitary cat after.
My first cat was like that, but I was 12 when I got him, so I played a lot with him. When he was adult, our home was just for food and sleep, he was always outside. He was still very affectionate with us when he was in the house.
My current cat is always in my legs and always meowing for nothing: He wants me to look at him when he eats!!!
When he was a baby, I was 30 and did not take time to be with him and play with him. Now, he is totally insecure.