Want a good place to get solid info about gear lube info and performance?
use this link:
https://p-r-i.org/pri-qpl/lubricant-review-institute/
look for the "QPL" (qualified product listing) link on the left side of the page.
This list is from a 3rd party testing site and has no bias for or against brands. Any lube on this list passed the SAE J2360 standards; a mil-spec equivilant.
There are a lot of brands/grades which actually are not on the list; common ones we'd see at our fav store, such as Mobil 1, for example. The absence of Mobil 1 on this list does not mean it's a bad lube; simply that it's not accreditted on the QPL. That could be for many reasons ...
- it was submitted and didn't pass
- it was not submitted because it wouldn't pass
- it was not submitted because they didn't want to bother with the approval, though it may well have passed, had they sought the approval
I cannot tell you why it's not on the list; I can only bring to light the fact that Mobil 1 gear oil is not on the list. Mobil does have several products on the QPL, so it's not like they aren't aware of the testing/approval process.
Other brands of gear lubes do have several of their prominent lubes on the list as well.