Originally Posted By: mechtech2
Anti seize is not a lube. It does not do well with water wash off - it is not meant to be exposed. It does not lube rubber to metal [some caliper pins are metal to rubber].
It is better than dry, I suppose.
Exactly.
Originally Posted By: Craig in Canada
BMW slides (my current concern) are specifically kept dry and unlubricated and are discs all around. Tiny dobs of paste are applied to the ears of the pads and the edge of the piston and that's about it.
BMW OE stuff is clear-yellow and feels a little odd - not quite like I would expect grease to feel. It also doesn't harden, dry or get tacky (unlike the squeal-stop products).
When shopping for brake "lubricants" these two classes of greases seem to be mixed interchangeably by helpful Internet folks, manufacturers, DIY instructions, and store clerks. I don't know exactly how people think that super high-temp grease (essentially) is going to work or act the same as that squeal-stop jelly that sets up and is meant to be applied to the entire rear surface of pads, yet most people don't know the difference. When grilled, they simply don't know.
I'm looking for top quality alternatives to the OE BMW stuff as my source for small quantities may have dried up (no pun intended) and I have a couple of BMW brake jobs coming this fall. Everything I see in local stores is generic junk which is unclear from the instructions which of the two kinds of material it is, but states it will be excellent at stopping squeal.
I don't know why BMW want them to be dry but I'm not going to argue with them.
Apparently they feel they effectively can keep any moisture out and the dry part may have less drag,who knows.The grease on the ears also helps to prevent that clack clack noise common on BMW,the Permatex green,ceramic and Plastilube(i believe plastilube is closest to OEM) work well in this application.
The greases,sprays and latex membrane type compounds applied to the back of the pads are all trying to reduce the high frequency vibration that can cause squeal in one way or another.
All are attempting to cure the symptom not the cause.Most pads have some sort of dampening device fitted to the rear of the pads from the manufacturer and should be adequate.
The main causes for high frequency vibrations are..
Loose fitting parts,e.g. using old weak retainers,worn pins or slides.Rusted piston face where it contacts the pad if severe.For this reason sanding down old pins when rusty or using old hardware is not recommended.
Basically anything that is not firm or has unwanted movement can cause these vibrations
Incorrect rotor finish,15 to 80 microinches is ok.The smoother the better,the use of rounded cutting tools is claimed to give a smoother finish when turning rotors and drums.
Pad material also can also play a role.Semi metallics and some of the exotics seem to be the worst offenders (i used a set of carbon/kevlar on my CBR 1100 years ago that squealed like a parrot with its foot caught) when it comes to noise,ceramic and organics the least.
Pads not correctly broken in and have glazed,contaminated pads.