Lexus RX330 Bad Analysis Results

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
96
Location
Pennsylvania
I started this as a new thread even though I posted this on page 2 of an older thread. I wanted to experiment with a 10,000 oil change and installed Mobil 1 5W-20 in my 2006 Lexus RX330. At 5900 miles on the oil (the vehicle has 41000), below is what Blackstone said. I'm disappointed and wondering exactly what's going on. It's possible, I guess, that the prior oil change at the dealer (with my oil) didn't drain all the oil or didn't change the filter, but they've generally been a good dealer so I can't assume they goofed. Any thoughts about this:

"Universal averages show typical wear for this type of engine after ~6,100 miles, so your wear metals are a little higher than average, but only lead (from bearings) is high enough to highlight. Silicon or sodium may show the cause; neither one is an additive in Mobil 1, so unless these are residual from a
previous oil, silicon might show dirt and sodium might show antifreeze. Neither is a big problem yet, but better to catch it early, so check the air filter and watch for a coolant leak. The TBN is good, at 2.8 (1.0 is low). Change this oil and check back in 6,000 miles."
 
want to list the whole uoa? they are saying you might have a poor air filter or coolant leak. I wouldnt expect any oil to perform well with either of those?
 
Try another 5-6k OCI with a different oil, and get another analysis done.

What's the coolant level currently?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: HyundaiGuy
If you are trying to go 10,000 miles, why not try Mobil 1 EP? That's the oil Mobil recommends for extended drain intervals.


XM does warrantee their M1 for 10K as well. If you are going to do UOAs you should do at least two OCs with the same oil.
 
Originally Posted By: tig1
Originally Posted By: HyundaiGuy
If you are trying to go 10,000 miles, why not try Mobil 1 EP? That's the oil Mobil recommends for extended drain intervals.


XM does warrantee their M1 for 10K as well. If you are going to do UOAs you should do at least two OCs with the same oil.


Definetly do 2 UOA's with the same oil, wonder what oil the OP was using before this Oil Analysis.
 
There is a reason why Toyota/Lexus recommends 6 month or 5k mile oil changes no matter WHAT oil you use.

Mobil 1 is not some magic oil (either is any other) and some vehicles do not do well past what the millions of miles of testing proved.

I'd stay away from extended OCIs (we don't know the history of the engine, use and without that info ANYONE or ANY company that gives blanket recommendations/advise I'd stay far away from)

Personally I'd go with a 5w30 and do a few 5k or 6month OCI, then run a UOA and see what you have.

Just my 2 cents.

Bill

PS: You are also going to hear about all the sludge cleaned up from this oil change and that skewed the OCI. Not going to agree unless your 5k oil changes were every 2 years.
 
The 3.3 is much much better than the 3.0, buy it's still not a great long oci motor. I agree with Bill, M1 is an excellent product but it's not a miracle in a bottle. 10,000 miles will likely be too much for most oils in this motor.
 
I also agree with Bill;
Quote:
I wanted to experiment with a 10,000 oil change and installed Mobil 1 5W-20 in my 2006 Lexus RX330.

I would say that your experiment is not going well. There are many factors which play into doing extended drains:
Before you switched what were your original oil change specs (duration, oil used etc)?
Did you do UOA on your previous oil to compare?


Whenever someone is interested in doing an extended oil drain getting some baseline trends about your engine and driving patterns will make a world of difference. So you test at 5K with your normal oil; then you pick your extended drain oil and run it for 5k to compare to see if that oil is going to stand up better in your engine then your previous. Then run for 7500 and check again. Then to 10 000. If at any point along the way you see things you don't like then you've reached the maximum OCI with that oil and your specific engine and driving patterns. You can never assume that just because an oil can go for 10K for someone else that it will do so for you.

*before someone cuts out my liver on that last bit I should qualify that you can make an educated guess based on other's results of similar circumstances but UOA is only valuable when there is a comparison otherwise there can be no certain conclusions drawn.
 
If someone be so kind as to tell me where and how to post the entire analysis (as a pdf or jpeg) I'll do it. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom