OMG... mine are so far off of the radar. And more than five.
BITOG gods: forgive me.
There are more than five but they don't have HP, speed or style as the hook, really.
Strange, off beat, misfit, ultra simple or basic. I don't know, they just grab me.
Several tiers:
'50s:
56 Hudson with "Vee-Line Styling"
57 Nash
57 Studebaker Scotsman
57 Packard Clipper
59 Studebaker Lark
Second Tier:
58 Rambler American
53 Henry J
54 Willys Aero
54 Kaiser Manhattan
55 Hudson
60s:
60 Comet
60 Rambler
60 Corvair
60 Valiant
60 Falcon
I've owned a 63 Valiant Signet for many years. Otherwise it would be on the list.
Second tier choices would be: 61 Mercury Monterey, 60 Edsel, 61 Tempest with slant 4, 61 Buick Skylark. 61 Olds F-85. Any VW Bug.
70s pickings are slim:
76 Pontiac Sunbird v6 [or wait till 77 for the Iron Duke] 2 door notchback.
71 AMC Gremlin
71-74 Hornet AMC Sportabout
78 AMC Concord
71 Mercury Comet
Second tier, I wouldn't kick any of these out of my driveway:
70-72 Ambassador
Any A Body Dart, Valiant, Coronet or Satellite with Slant Six
78 Chrysler LeBaron
79 Mustang, 4 or 6 [and I hated them at the time, go figure]
75 Datsun B-210 four door
71 Audi 100 [still beautiful]
70s Volvo 240 [gorgeous today compared to the tortured sheet metal, dumpy shapes and grimacing angry grilles]. I never appreciated them when they were no. Apologies to Volvo.
80s:
84 Citation notchback [right? I know all the lore, I had one and loved it. I'd love another one]
88 Cadillac Coupe DeVille
80 Olds Omega
The 85-86 Olds Calais would be on the list but I already have one.
Can't even find five from the 80s.
All from the Isle of Misfit Cars, folks.
Yes, I do ask myself, how did I get to this state??? I genuinely love them for what they represent and their back stories in the automotive timelines of the periods. They represent more than just the cars. Something like the Scotsman and bare bones basic cars represent an entire philosophy about personal finance. So many aspects.
I wish I could gin up more excitement about muscle cars and exotic stuff. That's just not where the ball landed on the wheel. All personal favorites, no shade thrown. I'd choose these cars with a lottery win.
Starting with a 1960 Comet: my ultimate dream car. The top choice from all of these.
OP: great thread.