Patman,
I have the ASX's as a winter setup on my BMW with the staggered setup of 225/45/17 front and 255/40/r17 rear. Some of the folks say they are a bit harsher but I can definitely say they are much softer than the RE050A RFT's that came with the car. Last Winter a little over 2 inches they did fine on unplowed roads. The only issue I have is with water refreezing over night and the tires do not do well in that regards. Other than that for the price and what you get I would definitely consider them. I just purchased two sets from discount tire when they had the $100 promo for my Dad's car. One point to make is depending on your driving pattern even though they have a treadwear rating of 420 don't expect to get over 30,000 if driven aggressively. Hopefully this will make your decision a little easier.
I have the ASX's as a winter setup on my BMW with the staggered setup of 225/45/17 front and 255/40/r17 rear. Some of the folks say they are a bit harsher but I can definitely say they are much softer than the RE050A RFT's that came with the car. Last Winter a little over 2 inches they did fine on unplowed roads. The only issue I have is with water refreezing over night and the tires do not do well in that regards. Other than that for the price and what you get I would definitely consider them. I just purchased two sets from discount tire when they had the $100 promo for my Dad's car. One point to make is depending on your driving pattern even though they have a treadwear rating of 420 don't expect to get over 30,000 if driven aggressively. Hopefully this will make your decision a little easier.