Originally Posted By: Hokiefyd
I've had two experiences with the Goodyear belts. One was good (Dodge Dakota) and one was not (Acura MDX). The bad experience didn't include a failed belt, but the durometer of the belt or similar property must not have been right, because it flapped around bad when the A/C was on. It would rattle the tensioner quite a bit. With the stock belt back on it, it was fine. I recently put a Dayco Poly Rib W belt on it and that one is good, too. I put a Dayco Poly Rib W belt on our other car, and it's good on that one as well. Try a Dayco. They also did a really nice Q&A on here a few months ago; always good to support a forum supporter.
Sorry to bump this from the dead, but I'm running into a belt sizing issue on a different application, so I looked up your 2005 MDX and this is what I found:
Dayco: 84"
Gates: 84.63"
Goodyear: 84.75"
I also looked up the serpentine belt for a Yaris, Accord and Elantra, and in all three applications, the Gates drive belt was 0.5" longer than the Dayco or Bando for the application.