How would an oil filter cause an engine tick?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: ZeeOSix
What's the criteria to categorize an oil filter as "high flow"? Especially when the oiling system is fed by a positive displacement oil pump.


Less restrictions inside the filter.
 
Originally Posted By: Triple_Se7en
Originally Posted By: ZeeOSix
What's the criteria to categorize an oil filter as "high flow"? Especially when the oiling system is fed by a positive displacement oil pump.


Less restrictions inside the filter.


Verified how?
 
Inlets and media have things to do with restrictions. So does the quality of the ADBV. Other parts too.

With 13K+ posts and probably a thousand in this filter room, I'm shocked you needed to ask that.
 
Originally Posted By: Triple_Se7en
Inlets and media have things to do with restrictions. So does the quality of the ADBV. Other parts too.

With 13K+ posts and probably a thousand in this filter room, I'm shocked you needed to ask that.


I'm asking it to see if you know what you're talking about. I'm well aware of restriction and exactly what causes it ... you should know that if you've been in this forum for the last 6 years.

So again, tell me what the criteria is to label a filter as "too restrictive", and exactly how you or anyone else would verify/determine the filter is too restrictive in normal use.

Is this filter "too restrictive" when used on an engine with a positive displacement oil pump?

 
Engine ticked on Synthetic Puro after an oil change, all I did was change the filter to RP, tick was gone. For those who know about hemi tick, it is more like a knock or a loud sewing machine. I'm sure many people could waste a lot words trying to convince me of some position, but I believe the difference was the flow of the RP filter was better. I need the synthetic media, I am on long OCI with redline.
 
Originally Posted By: burla
Engine ticked on Synthetic Puro after an oil change, all I did was change the filter to RP, tick was gone. For those who know about hemi tick, it is more like a knock or a loud sewing machine. I'm sure many people could waste a lot words trying to convince me of some position, but I believe the difference was the flow of the RP filter was better. I need the synthetic media, I am on long OCI with redline.


Both of those filters were full synthetic and both should flow very well. So sounds more like a bad ADBV on the Purolator.
 
Originally Posted By: dlundblad
Originally Posted By: SHOZ
How would an oil filter cause an engine tick?


Bypass design.
Too high PSI?
 
Originally Posted By: burla
Engine ticked on Synthetic Puro after an oil change, all I did was change the filter to RP, tick was gone. For those who know about hemi tick, it is more like a knock or a loud sewing machine. I'm sure many people could waste a lot words trying to convince me of some position, but I believe the difference was the flow of the RP filter was better. I need the synthetic media, I am on long OCI with redline.


It may have been a defective adbv in the Purolator. I have seen that on a new one I cut open. Or it may be whatever was blocking a passage freed itself when a new filter was put on. The initial slug of oil may have dislodged something after the blockage relaxed from backflow. To know you would have to try another filter of the same type. The Mopar I believe on Chrysler products have a base end bypass like Ford. The media on those isn't as high a grade as on the synthetic. I wouldn't attribute the problem solving to a RP filter which uses pretty standard Champ labs parts. But if it works, it works.
 
Originally Posted By: SHOZ
Originally Posted By: dlundblad
Originally Posted By: SHOZ
How would an oil filter cause an engine tick?


Bypass design.
Too high PSI?


I wouldn't think that would matter because different filter manufactures have different PSI settings for the same cross referenced filters. Fram with Subaru for example.

I am thinking more the design that anything else. Some engines seem to "prefer" one vs. the other.
 
Originally Posted By: SHOZ
Would the tick be caused by lack of oil flow?


If the engine ticks for a short time right after a cold start-up then it's most likely a leaky ADBV.

If the engine ticks all the time with filter A but not filter B, then it's a lack of oil flow issue. The only way there could be a lack of oil flow while running is if the filter is about totally clogged and/or the oil pump or pump relief valve are defective.

Make sure you don't have a counterfeit oil filter ... who knows how they flow. Probably the main reason for Hyundai/KIA engine noises.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom