Originally Posted By: JHZR2
If she is in your household, she is your liability regardless.
I learned that when looking at a geico insurance policy... My wife has never had an accident and has a clean record except one thing... A zero point cellphone ticket.
They tried to raise my insurance $300 because of the liability of something not officially on her record... And she had separate insurance and car!
Originally Posted By: PandaBear
Those extreme cheapness insurance (Geico and Progressive) both look at zero points ticket, and would ding you for every little thing out there.
Have her own car, own insurance, would limit the coverage but then it would cost more. You might as well pay more for a combined insurance in a "better" company that doesn't ding you for every little thing out there.
AAA, State Farm, All State, etc are better than Geico, Progressive, etc in this regard.
I had a similar experience- and it was with State Farm. I had been with them for some years at that point. My agent wanted me to ask my wife if she would try State Farm too. She thought it'd be worth a try, so she came in and gave all kinds of relevant info. It sounded good to her, so the agent wrote her a policy, sent the info off to SF corporate and she canceled her other. Well after SF corporate ran all of it, they found that her oldest boy (with a terrible record) lived with us and canceled her sight on spot and then sent me a noticed threatening to cancel me too. Boy was I ever furious!!!! All this because a driver with a bad record lived with us!!!
In the end, my (our) agent did some sweet talking and we both were able to retain our policies by signing a disclaimer that her son wouldn't be behind the wheel of our vehicles.