I eventually figured that out.
IMO you should get a stainless one. Of course, you can always opt for a steel transfer plate. These go on top of the induction plate, and the pot goes on top of that. Undoubtedly a bit less efficient, but likely still cheaper to run than resistance heat.
I see now that BMWTurbo suggested the same thing.
I need to be slower.
Oh well, pretty easy to find out. Just use a magnet.
All of my Kitchen Aid set works fine. Also a lot more aluminum stuff appearing on Amazon has been made to be induction compatible. The one trait that I commonly see, is a sort of DOT pattern on the bottom of the pan. I have an aluminum non-stick skillet that has that kind of bottom (WalMart) and it works very well on the induction range.
Anyway, we solved the OP's issue pretty well I'd say.