Originally Posted By: cmf
Originally Posted By: Letter_K
Popular Mechanics - Directions for doing a transmission flush. Ask here and you'll get different answers about running until the cooler line spit air. Some say run until it spits, others (my preference) like to do 2 or 3 quarts and refill through the dipstick hole. Looking above, most prefer to not take the chance running the pump dry.
http://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/how-to/maintenance/1272521
Can someone explain to me how running the pump until it stops pushing liquid is damaging to the transmission. I really don't understand this concept but it's reiterated very often on various forums. A link to an article on the damaging effects of this would be really appreciated.
And your link says: "Many professionals enhance this procedure by pouring a few quarts of fresh fluid into the dipstick tube at roughly the same rate that the old fluid is coming out, thus adding flushing action."
Sure that's fine and good, it's going to suck up any fluid in the pan that's above the level of the pump. It's basically faster than the service manual way but less fluid use conscious. However, it doesn't say how it's damaging to the transmission to run it until it pumps air. I really am thoroughly ignorant to how the pumping air damages the transmission.
I never said running dry would hurt the pump. My preference is better safe then sorry, but that is just my preference. I'm guessing the real reason why is that most see the fluid keeps the pump cool and lubricated.
Running dry and shutting off right away probably doestn't do harm and probably cuts the refills in half.
Why do we do what we do? Someone else gave a good reason and we said that sounds plausible. Look with a critical mind and you'll see it throughout BITOG and internet forums. Why is Pennzoil so popular here? It has factory cleaning power - why, because it was posted over and over again and Pennzoil marketing told us so. Same with Auto RX and many other products.
Some things get repeated so much they become gospel. There is probably a bit truth and a bit fiction in these ideas.
It's the same with stock tips. Why do people trust a hot tip from a stranger?
OK, I'll stop being a philosopher now.