Thx for the clarifications.
It's best to email B&S tech support to find out. I'm not aware of any aftermarket gas filler cap seal material made of viton.
But then again: we've been using E10 here in this region for over 18yrs now, and all my mowers (B&S, including those plastic tank + side-draft carb type with plastic filler cap style) are on E10, rubber seal still pliable.
Q.