When comparing different brands buy the one with higher solids (if they list that on the label if not maybe buy the brand with the heavier bucket) to avoid a watered down product that won't last. I haven't done a seal on blacktop in 20 yrs but when I did I used whatever was on sale and always got 4-5 yrs out of it. I have all concrete now and it is more of a pain then my old asphalt was.