Direct injection and timing chain tough on oil?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: Danh

Sorry, but aren't gasoline DI pumps electric? Every photo I've seen of DI pump who's a plastic body that would be mounted outside the engine.


Could you share your specific example? I don't know of any high pressure fuel pumps that aren't cam driven.
 
Originally Posted By: rooflessVW
Originally Posted By: Danh

Sorry, but aren't gasoline DI pumps electric? Every photo I've seen of DI pump who's a plastic body that would be mounted outside the engine.


Could you share your specific example? I don't know of any high pressure fuel pumps that aren't cam driven.


Go to Rockauto.com and look at photos of replacement fuel pumps for a couple recent DI engines: a 2012 Ford Focus and 2013 Honda 4 cylinder Accord. I'm sure other examples would look generally the same. I suspect these reside in the fuel tank, just like those in non-DI, gas vehicles.
 
Originally Posted By: Danh
Originally Posted By: rooflessVW
Originally Posted By: Danh

Sorry, but aren't gasoline DI pumps electric? Every photo I've seen of DI pump who's a plastic body that would be mounted outside the engine.


Could you share your specific example? I don't know of any high pressure fuel pumps that aren't cam driven.


Go to Rockauto.com and look at photos of replacement fuel pumps for a couple recent DI engines: a 2012 Ford Focus and 2013 Honda 4 cylinder Accord. I'm sure other examples would look generally the same. I suspect these reside in the fuel tank, just like those in non-DI, gas vehicles.


The fuel and and the direct injection pump are 2 different parts.

UD
 
Originally Posted By: Danh
Originally Posted By: rooflessVW
Originally Posted By: Danh

Sorry, but aren't gasoline DI pumps electric? Every photo I've seen of DI pump who's a plastic body that would be mounted outside the engine.


Could you share your specific example? I don't know of any high pressure fuel pumps that aren't cam driven.


Go to Rockauto.com and look at photos of replacement fuel pumps for a couple recent DI engines: a 2012 Ford Focus and 2013 Honda 4 cylinder Accord. I'm sure other examples would look generally the same. I suspect these reside in the fuel tank, just like those in non-DI, gas vehicles.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4M9BITr1zhg
 
I know the High Pressure Pump is driven off the cam by an additional chain in a 3.5 Ecoboost.

I'm not sure 2000+ psi is doable with an electric at those volumes.
 
Originally Posted By: UncleDave
Originally Posted By: Danh
Originally Posted By: rooflessVW
Originally Posted By: Danh

Sorry, but aren't gasoline DI pumps electric? Every photo I've seen of DI pump who's a plastic body that would be mounted outside the engine.


Could you share your specific example? I don't know of any high pressure fuel pumps that aren't cam driven.


Go to Rockauto.com and look at photos of replacement fuel pumps for a couple recent DI engines: a 2012 Ford Focus and 2013 Honda 4 cylinder Accord. I'm sure other examples would look generally the same. I suspect these reside in the fuel tank, just like those in non-DI, gas vehicles.


The fuel and and the direct injection pump are 2 different parts.

UD


Well, that explains it. Thanks. Learn something new every day.
 
Originally Posted By: chad8
I own a 2011 sonata. First generation DI. First owner went 3000+ miles between changes.
I go 7000 with Quaker state 5w20 conventional, which is OEM oil. 7500 is recommended interval.
Car has 58000 on it. Burns maybe 1/3 quart between changes. Hard on oil? Yes, but not any worse than other engines.
Main weak point is carbon in intake and injectors. I clean the throttle body and use good injector cleaner regularly . Also use top tier Costco fuel.
With a 120000 mile , 10 year engine warranty, I'll take my chances on longer oil changes.
I won't own it past 100000 anyway. I'm buying another . At almost 40 mpg on the highway, I wouldn't own any other kind of engine until battery or fuel cell technology gets better.
DI is the present and future. Get used to it.


Well like you said, you're not going to own the car past 100,000 miles anyway. And I agree, direct injection is here to stay (and that's a good thing).

What I keep hearing is that it's tough on oil, I'm not sure if that's true - I suspect it is. But like you said, it's here, it's going to stay, it has its advantages.

I think these systems are improving daily. They will get quieter, they will stop the carbon buildup problem. Not that you care - because you're getting rid of the car anyway - but using good fuel and throttle body cleaner isn't going to stop/clean the carbon buildup problem these engines create. The carbon buildup exists on the back of the intake valves mostly. The only way to remove that is to clean the back of the valve manually - because without an actual injector there, cleaners, solvents, fuel additives, won't actually get to that spot. It's like buying a colon cleanse, opening it, but instead of ingesting it...you pour it on your leg. It's not going to work.

As for the direct injectors themselves, yeah a good fuel is always nice, but any fuel flows out of those injectors at very very high pressures...at these pressures almost anything should keep those spray nozzles clean, I guess. But the problem is the valves are never getting touched...add that to leaky PCV valve systems dumping oil into the intake...nothing is cleaning those valves. Like someone else said - some cars are now using two fuel delivery systems...DI and traditional injection (which sprays the intake valve). Otherwise people have to have their intakes removed and get their valves blasted with walnut shells or scraped with special tools. It's a problem. And some people are also using an oil catch can to trap some oil before it enters the intake manifold.

But the fuel mileage increase is great, there haven't been many mechanical problems with the systems. I just wonder about the oil, because it does seems to get dirty quickly and I keep hearing that it's "tough" on the oil.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted By: Gene K
Originally Posted By: MinamiKotaro
used oil analysis on direct-injection engines come back fine. Some are flagged with caution for fuel %, but I've yet to see a DI engine that has trashed its oil in a recommended change interval.


Then you have not been watching 3.6 GM, 1.4L Turbo GM or Ford 3.5EB.

I've seen some 3.5EB that the IOLM called for 10,000 mi change and TBN was 0.1-0.3 on a synthetic with iron over 100 ppm. I've also seen some that went 10,000 mi with 1.0-2.0 TBN and sub-20 ppm iron on blends.


Wow those are some differing numbers. Those first readings? Good luck doing that and expecting your engine to last for 200,000 miles or more. Probably not going to happen. Or it will but they'll be using 1 quart of oil every 1,000 miles, start getting misfire codes and begin to hear some strange noises coming from under the hood.
 
Originally Posted By: doublebase
there haven't been many mechanical problems with the systems. I just wonder about the oil, because it does seems to get dirty quickly and I keep hearing that it's "tough" on the oil.


Think of it like this - the More HP you demand from the system the harder it is on oil for the high pressure pump to deliver it.

A cam lobe to drive a passenger car is typically a low lift 3 lobe deal- relatively low stress, but still an added friction and pressure point in the system.

As you ask for more and more volume at that high pressure the lobes increase in lift and number until you have 4 and even 5 lobes driving the pump.

Thats a lot of energy off a cam lobe.

Something like an ecoboost truck pump is going to add a lot more resistance and friction to deal with that than a mild passenger sedan pump.

UD
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom