Corroded and broken brake line - Planning on how to address?

JHZR2

Staff member
Joined
Dec 14, 2002
Messages
54,951
Location
New Jersey
On my 2008 ML320 diesel, I had noted that there was some chafing on the front brake hoses. I also have all of the service receipts from the previous owner and I knew when I bought it that a prior shop had noted the brake hoses needed to be replaced.

I set out to do the front this weekend, and the connections at the hard line were definitely iffy. The first one I did, I was able to get loose without straining the line, however, once I started to fully remove it, the line bent and started to leak. I could feel that the coating on it was fully damaged, and I guess it was just enough shearing from turning the fitting to cause the line to leak at a weak spot. The female fitting for the soft line is locked in place and unable to turn.

So I had this after trying to crimp and bend it to stop dripping:

IMG_2818.webp



Unfortunately, Mercedes no longer supports these lines. I have searched for the part number. I’ve been unable to find one. Apparently they’ve been discontinued and now Mercedes sends a coil of line with the appropriate fittings for a shop to flare and install. The factory service manual also provides the following, shown under a fair use doctrine:

IMG_2819.webp



Based on my understanding of reading elsewhere, and the first section of this manual, the union is allowed to be used as a repair, as long as the F flare is utilized. I assume that the DIN number is for what others call a bubble flare.

So I’m looking for advice on what to do. Usually I don’t buy cars that has spent their life in salty areas. New Jersey isn’t too bad, and the car is beautiful otherwise. But this is an area that is exposed to extreme wash, and obviously has suffered corrosion. So I should execute under the assumption that I will be doing at least four repairs, either complete or partial.

So my issues are as follows:

1. It seems like the best flaring tools and dies require placement into a shop vice. How viable is it for a newbie to cut a line that is already on the vehicle, flare it, with a new male fitting, and then install it into a union? Is there a F type flare die that is better for use in situ?

2. Bel metric and others offer premade flared lines which I would assume would be pretty perfect. For the current install at the front left I wouldn’t see an issue at all. I’m sure that I can route the hose so that it goes from the ABS pump to the standard location without much of an issue. However, see my assumption above. I’ll guess that at some point I’ll need to do all, and I have no idea if there’s already a union someplace in that system. So is it better to just bite the bullet and start to do the path mentioned in number one?

3. Regardless, I will need a decent tubing bender, and potentially one that is small enough to use in place. There is essentially a drip leg shaped like a J at the bottom of the hard line where it connects to the soft line. So I need to be able to make essentially full reversal in tight diameters in order to refit a line.

4. This is a job where to be frank, I’m not sure that I’ll have to do too many times. My older vehicles don’t see salt, and my new vehicles get rinsed and protected quite often. So I kind of have to wonder if it’s worthwhile to buy all the tools and parts and do this or just to form it out to a shop. I have a Jaguar specialist just a few blocks away from me, so I kind of think that it may be worthwhile to have them do the job and just handle all four corners in the interest of safety. But that means I have to get the vehicle backed out of my driveway safely down the street and into the shop. I was able to use a pair of sign cutters to crimp the line almost completely to prevent gravity flow. However, I doubt that it will do anything against actual pressurized flow. It will make a giant mess the second that I step on the brake pedal to start the vehicle. I need to start the vehicle to get out of my driveway. So, is there some kind of a cap that would be recommended that will allow me to do this, knowing that I will only have three blocks to go? I’m thinking maybe a Swagelok type cap fitting - something that doesn’t require me to have special tools, which would defeat the purpose of having a shop do the work, So is there a decent way to prevent complete loss of fluid And some level of use of brakes to go to a few blocks to the shop?

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Doesn't sound like you done this before. You might just want to get some estimates (over the phone) and have the job done at your trusted garage. Replace everything. Don't piece-part old and new lines together. Myself, I crawl underneath and start making measurements of the existing lines. . I buy galvonized sticks in various lengths to equate the original and put together with a union or two. You will need to match the fittings for your vehicle. I use a tubing bender and bend and form under the vehicle. I have never had another issue since the new lines outlast the vehicle. It's not that that bad of a job to do.
 
https://www.globalfastener.com/standards/detail_22281.html shows DIN74233 to be a normal metric bubble flare line nut. Once you creatively get the nub out you'll see the flare type for sure.

You can practice your flaring on a piece of line-- buy a couple feet more than you need, you'll practice cutting it as well. They do sell premade lines with metric ends. You'll probably need "master cylinder adapters" from the NAPA parts bin if you're not extremely lucky on both ends. Traditionally if I add a union it's a regular SAE double flare as the parts are cheaper/ more available.

Flaring under the car sucks as there's a perpetual slow drip of brake fluid getting on your flare tool, and dripping down your arm into your shoulder. It is a satisfying job though as far as DIY for $20 vs paying a shop $500-- they don't want to do it either. ;)

+2 on the copper nickel lines; Benz probably used something similar from the factory; I know Volvo did. Color won't be as copper-y as the aftermarket but the lines last longer. A universal preflared line might be worse steel that'll corrode as fast as a chevy.

Lines do fail often at the line nuts as that's a crevice where salt accumulates. Inspect the others carefully.
 
Get a pre-made hard line and inspect the other three.
The pre made and bent hard line has been discontinued by MB.
@JHZR2 Is this what you are looking for? Also which side?

https://mbparts.mbusa.com/v-2008-me...llCBwxHlrLdB9bkd2ufWpdsPUtnBlO1OGPmpwiR4jPey5

Try Pelican Parts also.
Driver side to start but I’m going to assume the others are in similar shape. The little drip end is where the salt and brine sits and corrodes in this design.

It says they have it, but if you try to buy it, it’s a mixed message of delivery by June, or product discontinued.

IMG_2820.webp


Pelican and the other online parts sources catalogs have gotten worse and worse too. Too many lousy search results, and they care more about selling tools and fluids.
 
This is a very easy repair and not too expensive to DIY. Working on rusted lines can be real trouble, do not try to loosen the line fitting from the hose, hold the line fitting with a quality line wrench and turn the hose of brake wheel cylinder off the line.If replacing the hose anyway just cut it off then use a box end on it.
Nicopp is the way to go, I like Cunifer and AGS line, they are the best quality. You need 3/16 (4.75mm) and bubble flare. Cut the line back as far as needed to get to good solid line, flare both ends and add a connector. The Nicopp bends easily just bend it over a wooden dowel or I use a small hot sauce bottle, bend it smoothly to avoid kinking it.

You need a small tubing cutter, a deburing tool and a flaring tool, no need to go all expensive simple tools will do a good job, when making flares use a drop of brake fluid on the part of the line in the flaring tool, it makes things much easier and cleaner.

Some tools, lines and fittings. fedhill are great to deal with.

http://www.fedhillusa.com/

https://www.homedepot.com/p/General...5-mm-to-12-7-mm-T-Handle-Reamer-130/309489883

https://www.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-...-Cutter-Multi-Use-Tubing-Tool-32975/202826771

https://www.amazon.com/OTC-4504-Stinger-Bubble-Flaring/dp/B0015PMZMU
 
This is a very easy repair and not too expensive to DIY. Working on rusted lines can be real trouble, do not try to loosen the line fitting from the hose, hold the line fitting with a quality line wrench and turn the hose of brake wheel cylinder off the line.If replacing the hose anyway just cut it off then use a box end on it.
Thanks. These lines are locked in place unless I did something wrong. It has spring steel pulling the rubber hose end into a hole in the bracket that locks the two nubs on the rubber end into place.

Bad photo, I know. All MB vehicles I’ve done hoses on use the spring steel piece, but this one locks into the bracket:

IMG_2818.webp


Here’s a new spring:


IMG_2830.webp


I’ll have to take a photo of the bracket, but it’s like a 12pt star, and two nibs on the female soft hose end engage to lock it and prevent it from rotating.

You can kind of see the nibs there:

IMG_2831.webp


If I’m doing something wrong, which certainly could be the case, please let me know.

Thanks for the other recommendations. At least as a quick fix it would make sense to diy. Capri seems to have a decent flaring tool that can be done in place.

Is having a union really that bad??!?
 
Without putting eyes on it I would say if replacing the hose anyway replace the spring and just cut the old one off with a cutoff wheel or dremel wheel on both sides of the hard line so you can pull it up enough to rotate it.
i saw the capri one, it looks good and a worthwhile buy but either style can easily be held by hand.
A union with flared ends is perfectly acceptable even for the TUV and can be found in some OE applications, what is not acceptable are compression couplings.
 
Gas line will be next.
Except it’s diesel ;)

The brake lines look perfect everywhere else. I’ll take a photo of the other side when I can. It’s like a drip loop and I guess they’re coated steel… the only a lot they are corroded is at the bottom of the loop. (Knocking on wood, lol).
 
Except it’s diesel ;)

The brake lines look perfect everywhere else. I’ll take a photo of the other side when I can. It’s like a drip loop and I guess they’re coated steel… the only a lot they are corroded is at the bottom of the loop. (Knocking on wood, lol).
I had a diesel Rabbit roughly around 1980. It had a short braided fuel line that connected the front steel fuel line to the rear steel fuel line. That fuel line would deteriorate over 30K to 40K miles. When installed new it was rubber and you could see the braiding when looking at the end. 30K to 40K miles later the braiding was on the outside and it would drip fuel. Rubber outside was gone.
 
When you're torquing your new line nut, it wouldn't hurt to back up with a vise grip on the metal end of the hose so you're not twisting that semi fragile clip.
 
Fully concur with @Trav on the copper/nickel brake pipe.

Only thing to add, although I have limited pictures handy, on my Bravada I replaced the entire brake pipe from the master cylinder to the rear calipers, with copper nickle pipe, with pre made ends (zero flaring). Ended up being super easy.

Here are a handful of pictures I have, does not show the run from the master cylinder, but gives an idea of how wasy it can be with zero need to flare a brake pipe. When you see the first picture, all of that was pre flared pipe.

IMG_0671 (1).webp
IMG_0667.webp
IMG_0666.webp
 
I had a diesel Rabbit roughly around 1980. It had a short braided fuel line that connected the front steel fuel line to the rear steel fuel line. That fuel line would deteriorate over 30K to 40K miles. When installed new it was rubber and you could see the braiding when looking at the end. 30K to 40K miles later the braiding was on the outside and it would drip fuel. Rubber outside was gone.

Knocking on wood again, all my 40YO diesels have soft fuel lines at the tank, and return hoses that are original.

The injector return lines, which are exposed to a lot more heat, and the fuel line that has the inline filter, those all get hard after many years and require replacement.

When you're torquing your new line nut, it wouldn't hurt to back up with a vise grip on the metal end of the hose so you're not twisting that semi fragile clip.
The spring clip allows anything in its bore to turn. It puts pressure in the direction of the fittings. Prevention from turning is a nib on the soft line female thread mating with a location on the bracket.
 
I should have posted closure of the issue here, but I posted in the thread about flares and nuts instead.


In the end, used nicopp cunifer UK line, a capri DIN flare tool, and stainless armor.

IMG_3102.webp
IMG_3108.webp
IMG_3116.webp
 
I have this job (times two and all four complete lines) in my future. The W205 seems to suffer from the same low quality brake lines that the W204 does.

I've been following both of your threads closely, especially in regards to the correct flares and fittings.
 
Did the other side today. Didn’t have the drip loop setup like the other side. My real intent was to replace the rubber lines, but the corrosion on the hard lines was what started me on this…

The other side wasn’t as bad by a long shot. But it was still corroded at the end, so I figured I’d swap it since I have the parts.

This one had a nice convenient straight section that was clean to make a connection.

Plug it:
IMG_3172.webp


So much easier with nothing dripping.

IMG_3177.webp
IMG_3178.webp
IMG_3179.webp
IMG_3181.webp


Then a pressure bleed. All good, I hope…


IMG_3182.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom