Chevron Delo ESi 80w-90 or Valvoline WB 75w-90?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jul 8, 2008
Messages
188
Location
WA
So, I went to pick up gear oil for my truck today. I was going to get the synthetic stuff, but decided just to be cheap and get plain old Valvoline white bottle. That's what I have in there now.

For some reason, I think I was thinking about my old truck, I got 75w-90 and 80w-90. I think the previous truck spec'd 80w-90 in the rear end. This truck does not.

I talked to some local Chevron dealers lately, and though most of them only deal in 5-gallon buckets, one sells by the case of quart bottles. Chevron doesn't make a dino 75w-90, so it is considerably more expensive, but they do have Delo ESi dino gear oil in 80w-90 for something like $54 for 12 quarts. I need just a hair under 6 qts per change, so that would be perfect for my next two changes--and really cheap!

I think Valvoline is $7/qt for 75w-90. It doesn't say synthetic, so I assume it's not, although most 75w-90 apparently is synthetic.

I plan to probably change every 30k as the manual specifies until out of warranty, then probably change to a 50k interval with synthetic. I don't currently tow (we'd like a teardrop or popup camper someday), but we do occasionally take long trips or camping trips with the truck loaded down.

The manual specifies 75w-85 in the front & rear diffs, and 75w-90 in the transfer case (all 1.1 quarts). Since it seems like 75w-85 is a Toyota-only thing, I'm not so sure I want to pay that.

Or, should I just blow the money and get a full synthetic? The budget right now is extremely tight, which is why the Delo is very very tempting.

One last thing I noted about the Valvoline. The 75w-90 bottles only list it as meeting GL-5 and MT1 spec, whereas the 80w-90 lists a whole boat load of specs, including a MIL spec. I noticed some of the synthetic 75w-90's said this, but the Valvoline white bottle 75-90 did not. Does that perhaps mean in Valvoline, the 75w-90 doesn't meet these specs if they aren't listing it on the bottle?
 
Originally Posted By: Y_K
ESI rivals the best syn lubes in the visc range. On par with the Delvac syn gear lube.


That's what I've heard. I use Chevron motor oil and have been happy with it. I guess my only concern is whether 80w-90 is too much of a deviation from 75w-85 or 75w-90. I can't imagine it is, but I guess I'm not a lubrication engineer.
 
The only current API gear oil spec's are MT1 and GL5. So, the Valvoline bottles would be listing all the current ratings that API oversees.
 
Originally Posted By: INDYMAC
The only current API gear oil spec's are MT1 and GL5. So, the Valvoline bottles would be listing all the current ratings that API oversees.


The other specs weren't API. They were Ford, GM, MIL, etc. API is probably the only one worth worrying about, though.

If the specs aren't to worry about, I guess it's just which is more appropriate for the application.
 
Wish I knew how critical is the difference for your particular application. Any way to find any stats on comparables on Yota discussion boards? Nothing beats the real life experience.
 
Based on the reputation of the Chevron 80W-90 ESI and its borate chemistry add-pack, I'm using this in the diff of my Honda S2000 (which calls for a straight 90 GL5/6).

Seeing as how nasty the oil was that came out of the diff, I'm going to drain this 1st fill of oil after about 3,000 - 4,000 miles and refill with the same.

Once I have about 10,000 - 12,000 miles on it, I'll drain and refill again ... but I'll send the used oil to Blackstone for a UOA. Given that I only plan on putting 4,000 - 5,000 miles per year on this car, this will take a few years, I'm afraid.
 
I think most people just go with 75w-90 all the way around on the Tacomas. I really want to use the Chevron because of everything I've heard and the price, though.

I dunno.. have to take the other stuff back tomorrow. Other than some Dexron for the power steering fluid, a case of Chevron costs only about $10-15 more than half a case of Valvoline. In fact, I think I could get a whole 5 gallon bucket for under $100.

The Valvoline white bottle 75w-90 that is in there now has given me no known issues in 20k-ish miles. Haven't opened the rear to find out, though.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom