Changed my vehicle batteries

The battery testers are nice. I try to test mine every oil change at minimum.

That said, I'm hesitant to rely on them with much confidence. I've seen batteries pass the test during an oil change only to fail a couple months later. Older battery, pass or not, seems I would still consider replacing it if finances allowed.

Admittedly, there could be something I'm doing wrong or do not understand about the process.
For sure a cell can short suddenly and kill the battery. Can happen to a new battery also - my record is 6 weeks on a Nissan OEM battery - whomever made those back in the day. Also had a couple Walmart batteries fail pretty early as well.

Still - nothing wrong with replacing batteries every few years.
 
For sure a cell can short suddenly and kill the battery. Can happen to a new battery also - my record is 6 weeks on a Nissan OEM battery - whomever made those back in the day. Also had a couple Walmart batteries fail pretty early as well.

Still - nothing wrong with replacing batteries every few years.

Just saying, I don't think a battery tester is the answer here to OP's concern.
 
Just saying, I don't think a battery tester is the answer here to OP's concern.
I was young and dumb back then now that I think about it, replacing that battery that was still good, but I don't think i've ever had it where a battery was just dead one day. Usually it gives you a warning for a couple weeks beforehand. In a way just changing out a bunch of batteries for the heck of it seems like throwing money away.
 
I was young and dumb back then now that I think about it, replacing that battery that was still good, but I don't think i've ever had it where a battery was just dead one day. Usually it gives you a warning for a couple weeks beforehand. In a way just changing out a bunch of batteries for the heck of it seems like throwing money away.
Yeah, I hear ya. Throwing out good parts is something I try to avoid. However, are you testing the battery every 2 weeks?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I hear ya. Throwing out good parts is something I try to avoid. However, are you testing the battery every 2 weeks?
Gets tested everytime I turn the key. Like I said, keep an open ear and listen to how fast it cranks with a good battery. I usually start all my vehicles with the door open so I can hear. You won't hear much with the door closed
 
I’m in the process of doing it as well. My wife’s 6 month old Altima battery failed with no warning at all. It sat for a week at the Detroit airport and was absolutely stone dead. Nissan replaced it, but still a major pain. My 2018 rogue has a 40 month old Everstart max that tested 85% healthy this summer, but now tests 59%. My 21 Altima was built in 11/20 and has the original. I bought a deka gold for each but it’s been to cold to get out there to do it. What’s up with battery quality anymore?
 
I am an advocate of changing a battery out every few years - so not saying that is bad. Just offering a additional option - a tester.

The cheapest tester will tell you not only health but internal resistance - which can help see if a cell is sulfating.

I was young and dumb back then now that I think about it, replacing that battery that was still good, but I don't think i've ever had it where a battery was just dead one day.

If you have a week or sulfated battery, a shorted cell can drain the battery in a couple days. So for example if your driving to work and back daily it stays charged, but if you park it for a long weekend or something, three days later you can turn the key and get nothing. I have had it happen more than once. A tester will show a higher than normal resistance on these batteries usually as well.
 
Proactively changing out a 6-year-old battery seems smart to me. You know it'll fail at the most inconvenient time, too.
I actually think the opposite. One should simply apply a load test, prior to doing that. Again, we're in this mindset that we can afford to throw away perfectly good things. On the one hand, it's great to be in such a position. I used to do that for 20+ years on brakes. I'd remove the hardware and see they were 50% used, and say, I'm already in here, might as well replace them. I even did the same for tires. That's why today, I'm very much against throwing away perfectly good tires at age 6, or age 10, depending on which unscientific determination one wants to use.

You are correct too--if it fails on the road, everything I say is out the window. But, doing a load test interjects some reality into the scenario.

p.s. my BMW made in USA exide battery was installed 2011, so I would have proactively (like I did the first time) thrown away 2 batteries in the interim and be close to throwing away the 3rd. It in fact uses the same battery as the OP's Traverse. I get this will always be the unpopular recommendation--do a load test on any battery to determine it's condition, before throwing it away. I'll never know why the reluctance, but it's there.
 
Two words to alleviate undue stress when a battery exceeds 5 years of age:

JUMP PACK
I've seen these in passing but never looked into them in any detail. Despite what others have posted I've had a complete battery failure with no warning - car started first try, drove to Walmart, tried to start and - "click" Wouldn't turn over at all.

An hour or so and one AAA rescue truck battery purchase later, I'm back on my merry way but somewhat chastened since I made sure that the rest of the family travel with jumper cables and mine are nowhere to be seen!

That said, the jump pack idea sounds great but how reliable are they ?

Seems to me that sourcing enough amps to start your engine will generate a lot of heat, especially in a compact battery cell. Are these one and done disposable devices? Or can you recharge them and use again later?
 
I've seen these in passing but never looked into them in any detail. Despite what others have posted I've had a complete battery failure with no warning - car started first try, drove to Walmart, tried to start and - "click" Wouldn't turn over at all.

That said, the jump pack idea sounds great but how reliable are they ?

Seems to me that sourcing enough amps to start your engine will generate a lot of heat, especially in a compact battery cell. Are these one and done disposable devices? Or can you recharge them and use again later?
I have an older sealed AGM unit that is 6 years old and still charges up to 85% and will start a 8 cyl. with a dead battery. I also have a 2 year old compact GooLoo GP4000 that is powered by Lithium Ion battery which only needs to be recharged every 9 months! The only concern is the potential risk of fire in any Li-Ion battery when exposed to a high heat environment. I don't carry the GooLoo jump pack in the truck when the outside temperature exceeds 90 degrees F.
 
Changed my car batteries today got cold feet and was pushing my luck. Changed out the battery on my 2018 Traverse it was the OE battery showing no weakness. Pontiac G6 beater GM battery battery I got for $20 installed early 2018 showing no weakness. Purchased new batteries from Costco


I like your thinking. (y)

My new policy is to change batteries early. I haven't got much time left, and I want to enjoy what's left of my sanity. Worrying about an f.-ing battery is officially off my list.

The Opinion of Everyone Else: Oh, my God, you're going to spend money, American hard-earned money, on a battery before you've been lifted by the side of the road? Are you crazy?
 
I like your thinking. (y)

My new policy is to change batteries early. I haven't got much time left, and I want to enjoy what's left of my sanity. Worrying about an f.-ing battery is officially off my list.

The Opinion of Everyone Else: Oh, my God, you're going to spend money, American hard-earned money, on a battery before you've been lifted by the side of the road? Are you crazy?
I'm with you I'm not getting younger or stronger. This winter my goal is to go through everything in my basement and toss out everything that I haven't used in years. It's not much but as I told my wife carrying it up the stairs are going to be a issue soon enough. Also going to paint the the main floor before I get to old to do it. All daughter's so I was always a one man band my dad had boy's he had a orchestra.
 
I've seen these in passing but never looked into them in any detail. Despite what others have posted I've had a complete battery failure with no warning - car started first try, drove to Walmart, tried to start and - "click" Wouldn't turn over at all.

An hour or so and one AAA rescue truck battery purchase later, I'm back on my merry way but somewhat chastened since I made sure that the rest of the family travel with jumper cables and mine are nowhere to be seen!

That said, the jump pack idea sounds great but how reliable are they ?

Seems to me that sourcing enough amps to start your engine will generate a lot of heat, especially in a compact battery cell. Are these one and done disposable devices? Or can you recharge them and use again later?
My kids and wife got jump packs for Xmas. I’ve only had a battery leave me stranded twice since I became a somewhat responsible family man and no notice was given by the battery. Just shot. I did a training session yesterday with the wife and sons. Today is with my daughter. Jump packs certainly have come a long ways.
 
Two words to alleviate undue stress when a battery exceeds 5 years of age:

JUMP PACK
I always wanted one but they typically cost as much or more than a replacement battery....so I would sooner but a new one and carry the old one as a booster. I Actually take my summer car battery out in winter and bring it for backup in my truck.
 
I remember one time I did this and the parts guy thought I was nuts. Pretty sure he took my perfectly fine 4 year old battery and put it in his car. Not like they ever die at a convenient time.
Absolutely technicians don't throw out batteries if they test good. I worked with them and if someone requested a new battery "just to be safe" that old battery is absolutely getting charged and tested and kept by someone if it's ok.
 
I always wanted one but they typically cost as much or more than a replacement battery....so I would sooner but a new one and carry the old one as a booster. I Actually take my summer car battery out in winter and bring it for backup in my truck.
Here's the one mentioned a few comments up. $90, cheaper than most batteries and way easier to lug around. Will even boost diesels.

GOOLOO GP4000 Jump Starter 4000A Peak Car Starter (All Gas,up to 10.0L Diesel Engine) SuperSafe 12V Lithium Jump Box,Auto Battery Booster Pack,Portable Power Bank with USB Quick Charge and Type C Port https://a.co/d/hkYnEAL
 
My kids and wife got jump packs for Xmas. I’ve only had a battery leave me stranded twice since I became a somewhat responsible family man and no notice was given by the battery. Just shot. I did a training session yesterday with the wife and sons. Today is with my daughter. Jump packs certainly have come a long ways.
How did the training go with your daughter? I have 3 for my own sanity I never attempted to train them on anything car related but I regret it now considering there all with guys that are far from handy. Great guys but really useless to even check the oil level.
 
How did the training go with your daughter? I have 3 for my own sanity I never attempted to train them on anything car related but I regret it now considering there all with guys that are far from handy. Great guys but really useless to even check the oil level.
The problem with jump packs is the battery on those is usually dead too. 🙄
 
pick up a jump pack and keep it in the equinox , those original delco batteries run an amazingly long time if treated right

The OEM ACDelco battery in my 2015 Equinox went 4.5 years. Replacement Autocraft from AAP went 5 years. Just recently installed an Interstate from Costco to replace the AAP battery. I have never been able to get more than 5 years out of any battery, regardless of brand of battery or make of vehicle.

Shortest battery life was the OEM battery in a 2011 Hyundai. Died just after the 3yr warranty, of course (Hyundai's "best warranty in America" only covers wet-cell batteries for 3yr/36K miles...and even then it is a prorated warranty.)
 
Back
Top Bottom