Originally Posted By: brave sir robin
I am a huge Giants fan and this NLCS features two teams and fan bases I am highly annoyed by. A battle of yuck and worst possible yuck. I wish the Pirates were still in it because now I have to hope some clownball team wins
Despite my hate for all things dodger saying Matt Adams is anywhere near the hitter Puig is flat out laughable. Puig will get consideration for MVP this year. The Cardinals are among if not the best run teams in all of baseball (Matheney despite being a good Giant
was exposed during last years NLCS) but their fans seem to think that all of their players are the best ever n stuff. It's not just me saying that. I hear it from fans of other teams as well.
Since Puig plays for the Dodgers, he gets the media coverage.
Lets look at both players.
Puig - .319/19/42
Adams - .284/17/51
Puig is good player, but so is Adams.
As far as fanbases go, go to either a Dodgers or Giants game and your life is at risk. Opposing teams fans are not treated badly in St. Louis.
I don't think the Cardinals have the best players at each position. Shortstop is a work in progress, I like David Freese, but he's nowhere near the best overall 3rd baseman in the league, Matt Holliday is a real good player, but not the best, Jon Jay is serviceable in CF, Beltran in LF is good, but not the best, Matt Carpenter is among the leagues best at 2nd, Craig and Adams man 1st base very well.
The only position the Cardinals have what I feel is the "best" player is Molina at catcher.