I have a Cadillac XT4 and it's only had one minor issue that GM has corrected with an upgraded part (EVAP purge pump). I would get the XT5, which is a little bigger but with GM's same 2.0L four cylinder and 9 speed auto which is a proven reliable powertrain. My XT4 is all wheel drive and it gets over 30 mpg average with recommended (but not required) premium fuel. These are still union made in the USA if that matters.