I never had noise in the winter that way, irrespective of filter size or ADBV material. In any case, I sometimes use the specified size, but upsize sometimes because that's all there is, but generally, the upsize on the G37 is actually cheaper, whether I'm looking at the old Wix spec (51365 versus 51356) or the new one (51358 versus 57356) or the Baldwin (B1400 versus B1402).
LEADED: A few years back, Acklands wanted like over $20 for the Baldwin filter. They obviously realized that was nuts and dropped it to under $5.